Big Tech seeks route to overturn under-16 social media ban
Google, Meta and Roblox defend child safety tools as peers question whether platforms are making children safer online
Google, Meta and Roblox have urged the UK to focus on making online services safer for children rather than pushing through an under-16 social media ban, arguing that tougher enforcement of the Online Safety Act (OSA) could provide an alternative to prohibition.
The government plans to introduce a social media ban for under-16s in spring 2027, covering Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Snapchat, Facebook and X. Livestreaming and communication with strangers on other services, including gaming platforms, could also be restricted.
Giving evidence to the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee on Tuesday, Katie O'Donovan, director for government affairs and public policy at Google UK, Tim Scott, senior director for public policy, EMEA at Roblox, and Rebecca Stimson, director of public policy UK at Meta, argued that strengthening legislation would be a preferable route. They insisted the OSA is changing how their companies operate, that safety is a top concern and that new measures are being put in place all the time.
The committee’s investigation into the effectiveness of the OSA follows a report by regulator Ofcom published in October 2026 which found there had been no significant change in the proportion of children encountering harmful content over the nine months since the OSA's children's safety duties took effect in July 2025.
How Google, Meta and Roblox say they protect children
The tech representatives mentioned several recent child safety improvements.
Google’s O'Donovan pointed to SafeSearch being locked on for users known or inferred to be under 18 and changes to YouTube recommendations to reduce potentially harmful material. Meta’s Stimson highlighted private-by-default Teen Accounts, age detection and safer feeds, while for gaming platform Roblox Scott cited face-based age estimation and separate, more restricted experiences for younger users.
The companies were fulsome in their praise for Ofcom, describing the watchdog as technically knowledgeable. Scott said its engineer-to-engineer engagement was particularly effective, while O'Donovan called the regulator "exacting and very thorough".
Peers question whether children are any safer online
However, peers repeatedly countered the companies' descriptions of technical advances with evidence of failure to prevent children seeing harmful material.
After O'Donovan outlined Google's recent measures, committee chair Baroness Keeley responded: "No, they're not safer, are they?" while Lord Knight told Meta: "I'm sure you believe all of that", but evidence received by the Committee indicated that "things are getting worse, not better".
Viscount Colville listed a number of incidents reported by the Molly Rose Foundation, including “su” in a Meta search autocompleting to a suicide forum, while other peers mentioned the continuing appearance of anorexia posts, skin whitening ads and pornography in children’s feeds found by researchers.
Several exchanges revealed a contrast in how success is measured by tech companies and legislators. The former focused on safety spending, age detection, moderation systems, risk assessments and AI, while the peers concentrated on outcomes and what children actually encounter online.
Transparency and accountability: the UK-EU-US divide
Transparency was another area of contention. Lord Tarassenko questioned why companies publish fuller risk assessments under the EU's Digital Services Act while only providing summaries in Britain. He also challenged Meta over the recent US teen-safety settlement in which the tech giant agreed to provide an independent auditor with access to data, systems and staff, asking: "Why should the UK be second class with respect to the US?
The committee repeatedly asked why stronger safeguards had arrived so late. Baroness Keeley wondered why Roblox had not introduced protections sooner given its extensive reach among children, while Lord Storey said evidence suggested tech companies had had to be dragged "kicking and screaming" towards tightening online safety.
Age verification, privacy and implementation questions
Committee members were equally vigilant about apparent attempts to deflect responsibility elsewhere. Meta advocated age verification at operating-system and app-store level, while Google argued that app developers should be responsible for checking users’ ages. Scott's suggestion that online safety was a "shared endeavour" prompted a question about whether he was suggesting parents should be responsible, to which he replied “not remotely”.
However, there are genuine trade-offs and complexities when attempting to restrict content to certain groups. More intrusive age verification may improve child safety while also raising privacy concerns.
Cutting children off altogether may eliminate some risks while denying them access to information, online communities and opportunities to learn. Protective measures inevitably lead to a search for workarounds, making this a long-running game of cat and mouse as technology advances, and there may be wider free speech and implementation concerns.
Could safer platform design avert or reverse the UK under-16 ban?
The industry representatives said they hope their safety measures and cooperation will lead to a reversal of the likely ban, suggesting the way forward is to regulate the features creating harm rather than excluding young people completely.
For Meta, Stimson said the government has indicated there "might be a way back from a ban" during 2027.
Google’s O’Donovan said: "Rather than thinking about the age it's thinking about the product, it's thinking about the design, it's thinking about the feature." She pointed to approaches that could restrict harmful functionality, allowing platforms to redesign services around children.
However, convincing the government to change course will likely require the industry to resolve the point peers repeatedly pushed: it’s not whether companies are doing more, but whether children are demonstrably safer because of it.
In the meantime, several tech companies including Meta, X and TikTok all attempted to sue Ofcom over aspects of its implementation of the OSA.