Brazil carries out world’s largest desktop virtualisation project

17 Feb 2009

Comments: 5

A Computing logo
children with computers
Virtualisation project will provide computing education to millions of Brazilian children

More than 350,000 virtualised desktops will be introduced to Brazilian schools in what is claimed to be the world’s largest-ever implementation of the technology.

Virtual desktops are to be used in all Brazil’s 5,560 municipalities, with software and hardware costing less than $50 (£35) per seat.

Further reading

The project is an initiative from the Brazilian Ministry of Education and will see every computer converted into up to 10 independent workstations running the Linux operating system, which will be used in the education of millions of schoolchildren.

It is claimed that the low-cost set-up is equal to savings of 60 per cent in up-front costs, 80 per cent in annual power savings and further cost efficiency in ongoing administration and support costs, in comparison to a traditional PC.

Some 18,750 workstations have already been rolled out in rural schools during the first phase of the project.

According to the vendors handling the implementation, the initiative saves more than 170,000 tons of carbon emissions yearly, the equivalent of taking 28,000 cars off the road, or planting 41,000 acres of trees.

Suppliers Userful and ThinNetworks are providing the desktop virtualisation and PC sharing software respectively, while Positivo, Daruma, and Itautec are supplying the PCs and service.

Since 2003, when Luis Inacio Lula da Silva became president, the Brazilian government made a number of attempts to introduce cheap computers on a large scale for schools but the efforts were traditionally hampered by red tape, tax disadvantages, competition issues, deficient tendering processes and political wrangling.

In 2006, the nationwide programme for eradicating illiteracy launched by Lula began to gather pace and part of the plan was an initiative to investigate the use of laptops in education. The scheme, named “Um Computador por Aluno” – which stands for one computer per student– was related to the struggling One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) project.

Late that year, five pilots began in schools as a way to gather learning experiences before starting a national scale scheme, two of them using equipment from OLPC.

Since then, the project has stalled – allegedly due to budgetary restrictions – but last month, the co-ordinator of digital inclusion at the Brazilian government, Cezar Alvarez, guaranteed that the 150,000 laptops planned for school use will finally be distributed this year.

Large-scale introduction of computers in schools has been since heavily criticised by education experts worldwide, who argue there is no evidence that the equipment will help children to learn or that technology would help reduce illiteracy rates as well as poverty, some of the most pressing socio-economic issues in Brazil.

Reader comments

desculpe a nossa falha!

Obrigada pela observacao, Sergio, e desculpe a nossa falha!

Posted by: Angelica Mari  23 Feb 2009

What about basic education?

As a software developer professional I see this as a great initiative of our government, but as a citizen I feel bad because basic education is still forgotten. If was not forgotten we do not have great news in that area. What we see every day at TV news is the bad situation of schools, the transport of students, and the teacher's salary.

Posted by: Rogério Alcântara Valente  20 Feb 2009

Some small errors in the article

- The name of one of the suppliers is Itautec, not Itaultec. (look at their site at http://www.itautec.com.br )
- 'Um Computador por Aluno' means one computer per student, not one computer per child.

Posted by: Sergio Queirow  20 Feb 2009

Compare this to the UK efforts

I think it was only last week that Computing was talking about similar plans in the UK, but it's interesting to observe how Brazil - supposedly a 'developing' country - can be so much more advanced in their thinking...

Posted by: Mark Koabyashi-Hillary  18 Feb 2009

OLPC uses less power

OLPC uses less power than the screen and the thin client.

Each child having their own laptop makes it possible for children to use the laptop as an ebook reader, thus learning to read. You can't learn to read on a shared desktop.

There is ample proof that computers improve the situations of children in developing countries. Tons of proof out there.

Posted by: Charbax  17 Feb 2009

Have your say on this article

All fields required. Your email address will not be displayed on the site.

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

  • Digg
  • Tweet

Newsletters

Sign up for our FREE newsletters

Will Google’s new privacy policy impact how you use its services?

Google recently said will consolidate more than 60 of its privacy policies into one, unifying customer data across most of its products. The announcement has met with a backlash in the US, while EU officials have asked Google to put its plans on hold so it can assess the privacy impact for users. Will you consider not using Google in the future as a result?

81 %

4 %

3 %

12 %