Meta and Google found liable for intentionally creating addictive platforms
Both are appealing collective $3m fine
A California jury has found Meta and Google liable for intentionally designing addictive platforms that harm young users.
Meta and Google parent company Alphabet have been found liable by a California jury for intentionally creating addictive platforms to hook young users. The lawsuit was bought by a 20-year-old woman who alleged that YouTube and Instagram were designed to be addictive.
Meta and Google have been ordered to pay $3 million in compensation. Meta will pay the lion's share of that sum at 70% while Google pays the remaining 30%. There is also the possibility of additional punitive measures against the tech giants as the court continues assessing this case.
A deliberate intention to hook users
The verdict may have some serious and expensive implications for Big Tech as a host of other liability cases are still ongoing.
Late last year it was reported that Meta deliberately shut down a research programme into the mental health of users.
The case was bought by a young woman who alleged that Meta and Google deliberately designed their social media sites with features to not just engage young people, but to hook them on the platforms. Recommendation algorithms and infinite scrolling were cited, and the woman alleged that her subsequent social media addiction from such a young age contributed to psychological harms such as body dysmorphia, depression and suicidal thoughts.
Meta and Google denied being responsible for these harms. The jury disagreed and ruled that the tech companies' negligence played a "substantial factor" in mental health harms.
Google was deemed to have failed to adequately warn young users about the dangers of using YouTube. It plans to appeal, apparently on the basis that the case “misunderstands YouTube" as a social media site, instead of a streaming platform.
Meta will also appeal. "We respectfully disagree with the verdict and are evaluating our legal options," a Meta spokesperson said in a statement. Google plans to appeal, apparently on the basis that the case “misunderstands YouTube" as a social media site, instead of a streaming platform.
TikTok and Snap were part of the original lawsuit but settled out of court with the plaintiff earlier this year.
Mark Zuckerberg’s terrible week
Two days ago, a separate jury in New Mexico imposed a $375m fine on Meta after finding that the company allowed child sexual exploitation and misled consumers about the safety of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.
"The era of Big Tech invincibility is over," said Sacha Haworth, executive director of The Tech Oversight Project. "After years of gaslighting from companies like Google and Meta, new evidence and testimony have pulled back the curtain and validated the harms young people and parents have been telling the world about for years."