Meta accused of burying research linking Facebook use to teen mental health harms
Court documents say Meta halted internal research showing reduced Facebook use eased anxiety and depression
A legal brief indicates that Meta shut down a research programme into the impact of the Facebook on users’ mental health. Other social media platforms such as YouTube and TikTok are accused turning a similarly blind eye to harms.
The filing, released Friday by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, is part of a long-standing multi-party lawsuit bought by a group pf school districts, parents and state attorneys.
It accuses social media companies including Meta, TikTok, Google and Snap of being aware of that their platforms were harmful to the mental health of children and young adults and of effectively suppressing that information.
According to internal Meta documents, obtained via discovery, in 2020, Meta scientists worked with survey firm Nielsen on ‘Project Mercury’ which aimed to quantify the effect of “deactivating” Facebook. The documents said that “people who stopped using Facebook for a week reported lower feelings of depression, anxiety, loneliness and social comparison.”
Instead of making these findings public or researching further, the filing states that Meta killed the project and internally declared that the findings were tainted by a negative “existing media narrative” around the platform.
Despite Meta’s own research finding at least a link between the use of its platforms and negative mental health effects, the company told Congress that it had no ability to quantify whether its products were harmful to teenage girls and that there was no evidence of links between mental health harms and social media use.
In a statement to Politico, Meta spokesman Andy Stone said the study was stopped because its methodology was flawed and said:
“The full record will show that for over a decade, we have listened to parents, researched issues that matter most, and made real changes to protect teens”.
Allegations against Meta and other social media platforms include tacitly encouraging children below the age of 13 to use their platforms and failing to address child sexual abuse content and seeking to expand the use of social media products by children when at school.
The plaintiffs also allege that the platforms attempted to pay trusted, child-focused organisations to defend the safety of their products in public.
A Google spokesperson said in a statement that “These lawsuits fundamentally misunderstand how YouTube works and the allegations are simply not true.” There has been no comment yet from other companies named in the filings.
The list of allegations against Meta is longer than that against other platforms and includes intentionally designing youth safety features to be ineffective and difficult to use and blocking the testing of safety features that it feared might harm the growth of its user base.
Andy Stone’s statement disputes these and other allegations and said the company’s safety work was “broadly effective.”
"We strongly disagree with these allegations, which rely on cherry-picked quotes and misinformed opinions,” Stone said.
Not the first time
This isn’t the first time Meta has been accused of keeping its own findings about the impact of its platforms on mental health quiet.
In 2021, a report in The Wall Street Journal said that Instagram’s own research which consisted of focus groups and online surveys conducted over several years showed that the company was aware of the toxicity of its own products for the mental health of teenage girls. The report said that a 2019 presentation slide said that:
"We make body-image issues worse for one in three teenage girls"
In 2020, research found 32% of teenage girls surveyed said that Instagram made them feel worse about their bodies and some 13% of UK teenagers and 6% of US users surveyed traced a desire to kill themselves to Instagram.
Karina Newton, Head of Public Policy at Instagram said of The WSJ story at the time:
“Whilst the story focuses on a limited set of findings and casts them in a negative light, we stand by this research. It demonstrates our commitment to understanding complex and difficult issues young people may struggle with and informs all the work we do to help those experiencing these issues.