Meta ordered to pay total of $942m in child safety case

Ruling requires Meta to introduce a series of measures to reduce the risks faced by children and teenagers

A US judge has ordered Meta to pay a further $567m after ruling that its social media platforms contributed significantly to a youth mental health crisis in New Mexico.

The latest penalty comes on top of a $375 million fine imposed in March, taking the total amount Meta has been ordered to pay in the case to $942 million.

The ruling also requires the technology giant to make changes to how its platforms, including Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp, operate for young users in the state.

The lawsuit was brought by New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez in 2023, alleging that Meta exposed children to sexually explicit content, solicitation and human trafficking.

Judge Bryan Biedscheid had previously found that Meta violated the state's Unfair Practices Act by using recommendation algorithms that directed young users towards harmful content.

The latest ruling followed a request for the court to decide whether the company had also violated New Mexico's public nuisance law. The judge concluded that it had.

"Significant numbers of people in New Mexico experience harm from Meta's products due to risks of sexual exploitation, interference with education, and adverse mental health outcomes," the court order [pdf] said.

Judge Biedscheid pointed to evidence of worsening mental health among young people in the state, including increased rates of depressive episodes and suicide.

He said features designed to maximise user engagement had contributed to problematic social media use, citing research from the US Surgeon General.

Although the judge acknowledged that Meta was not solely responsible for the crisis, he said its platforms were a "significant contributing factor".

Restrictions imposed on young users

The court has ordered Meta to introduce a series of measures aimed at reducing the risks faced by children and teenagers.

Like counts will have to be removed for young users, unless they have permission from a parent or guardian to view such metrics.

Push notifications to under-18s must also be suspended between 22:00 and 07:00. The ruling limits underage users to 90 hours of platform use a month – roughly three hours a day.

Meta must also strengthen measures to prevent children under 13 from using its services and maintain protections for teenage users.

About $420m of Thursday's penalty will go towards community and family-based treatment programmes. Additional funds will support prevention efforts addressing the harmful behaviour identified in the case.

The judge compared the effects of social media to pollution, arguing that the harm created by Meta's platforms extends beyond individual users.

Meta to appeal as more cases mount

Meta said it would appeal.

"We work hard to keep people safe on our platforms and have been transparent about the challenges of identifying and removing bad actors and harmful content," a company spokesperson said.

The case is one of a growing number of legal challenges alleging that social media companies deliberately design products that can be harmful or addictive to children.

In March, a California jury found Meta and Google liable for intentionally designing addictive platforms that harm young users.

Meta is also facing a major case brought by 33 US states, which has been consolidated in federal court in Oakland, California.

Other states, including Tennessee, have filed separate lawsuits.