AI companies are influencing global regulatory agenda, researchers warn

'Big AI' using tactics seen in tobacco and oil industries

Researchers have accused major AI companies of influencing governments and regulators using tactics similar to those employed historically by the tobacco, pharmaceutical and oil industries.

A new academic study claims some of the world's largest AI firms are engaging in "regulatory capture" – a process in which public institutions intended to protect citizens instead begin acting in the interests of industry.

The report was produced by academics from the University of Edinburgh, Trinity College Dublin, Delft University of Technology and Carnegie Mellon University.

Their paper, titled Big AI's Regulatory Capture: Mapping Industry Interference and Government Complicity, examined how AI firms seek to shape laws, public debate and oversight mechanisms around the rapidly growing technology sector.

Claims of 'narrative capture'

The researchers analysed 100 news reports linked to four major AI policy events between 2023 and 2025, including negotiations surrounding the EU AI Act and international AI summits held in the UK, South Korea and France.

They identified several recurring patterns of influence, including lobbying, legal manoeuvring and "narrative capture".

According to the report, narrative capture occurs when companies steer public discussion and policymaking towards positions that benefit industry interests.

Researchers said one of the most common arguments advanced by technology firms was that strict regulation could damage innovation and economic competitiveness.

The study argues that this framing has increasingly shaped political debate around AI governance.

It points to calls within the European Commission to "simplify" elements of the EU AI Act before parts of the legislation have fully taken effect.

Researchers argue the language resembles tactics previously used by powerful industries to push back against tighter controls.

The paper also highlights the "elusion of law" – the use of loopholes or contested interpretations of legislation.

Researchers said this included alleged attempts to avoid or weaken rules relating to antitrust, privacy, copyright and labour protections.

The study identified the "revolving door" between government and industry as another significant issue, referring to officials moving into private-sector technology roles or industry figures taking positions within public institutions.

Dr Abeba Birhane, director of Trinity's AI Accountability Lab and lead author of the research, said AI companies frequently rely on claims that regulation "stifles innovation" to justify lighter oversight.

She said these arguments risk allowing firms to dominate the wider public conversation around AI.

Co-author Zeerak Talat said the way governments regulate AI could affect public trust, scientific credibility and democratic systems.

"The regulatory and oversight structures and processes that govern the industry deeply impact everything from fostering public trust in systems marketed as AI to the credibility of scientific knowledge…the environment, rule of law and even the integrity of democratic processes," he said.

Lessons from other industries

The report argues policymakers should learn from previous efforts to regulate industries including tobacco, pharmaceuticals and fossil fuels.

Researchers called for stronger separation between public officials and private technology firms, alongside tougher rules governing lobbying and conflicts of interest.

The study also recommends greater support for independent journalism, civil society groups and external auditing of AI systems.

It suggests labour organisations and marginalised communities should play a larger role in shaping future AI regulation.