Stability AI wins key ruling in Getty Images copyright clash in the UK
Getty remains deeply concerned about the protection of creative works
Getty Images has largely lost its lawsuit against Stability AI in the High Court of London, in a closely watched case with major implications for the future of AI and copyright law.
Getty Images had accused Stability AI of breach of copyright and trademark infringement, arguing that Getty images were used without permission to train AI company's image generation tool Stable Diffusion.
In her decision, Judge Joanna Smith ruled that Getty had succeeded "in part" on its claim of trademark infringement, after finding that some users of Stable Diffusion had generated images displaying Getty's watermark, potentially confusing consumers about their origin.
However, she said her findings were "historic and extremely limited in scope."
Crucially, the judge dismissed Getty's claim of secondary copyright infringement.
"An AI model such as Stable Diffusion which does not store or reproduce any copyright works (and has never done so) is not an 'infringing copy'," the judge ruled.
The decision dealt a blow to Getty, which dropped part of its copyright case mid-trial, citing difficulties in proving where and how Stable Diffusion was trained. In a statement, Getty Images said it remained "deeply concerned that even well-resourced companies such as Getty Images face significant challenges in protecting their creative works given the lack of transparency requirements."
The company called for stronger government action, urging the UK to introduce transparency rules that would require AI developers to disclose the data sources used in training their models.
Stability AI, for its part, welcomed the decision. Its general counsel, Christian Dowell, said the ruling "ultimately resolves the copyright concerns that were the core issue," adding that the company was "pleased with the court's ruling on the remaining claims in this case."
"Getty's decision to voluntarily dismiss most of its copyright claims at the conclusion of trial testimony left only a subset of claims before the court," Dowell noted. "This final ruling ultimately resolves the copyright concerns that were the core issue."
Intellectual property experts said the decision clarified, at least for now, how UK law treats the use of copyrighted material in AI training. Simon Barker, Partner and Head of Intellectual Property at law firm Freeths, described the case as "where intellectual property meets AI."
He said the High Court had "drawn a line" by confirming that training an AI model on copyrighted works does not constitute secondary infringement, provided the works are not stored or reproduced in the model itself.
"AI developers can take some comfort from the case that the mere act of training on large datasets will not of itself expose them to liability for copyright infringement in the UK," Barker said.
"However, the judgment also serves as a warning that if AI-generated outputs reproduce protected trademarks, for example where they appear as watermarks, in a way that could confuse people then they will risk infringing those trademarks. Each case will turn on its own facts and rights holders will need to evidence a likelihood of confusion or association with the relevant trademark to succeed."
He added that the ruling "strikes a balance between protecting the interests of creative industries and enabling technological innovation," predicting it would influence future litigation and policy debates both in the UK and internationally.