Exclusive: Palantir partnership was 'flawed from the outset' says former NHS CIO

Palantir will remain at the heart of NHS data until 2029 as the government looks for a UK-led alternative

A former NHS and clinical research CIO has exclusively told Computing that the NHS's partnership with controversial US data company Palantir was "flawed...from the outset."

“Technology that successfully creates a transformation in any organisation needs to build understanding, acceptance and ultimately enthusiasm," they said.

"The partnership with Palantir to create the NHS Federated Data Platform was flawed in its very nature from the outset. Engagement with those that need to implement it was never achieved, the controversy about the procurement was never removed and the links to political sway never clarified."

Palantir's involvement in the £330 million FDP contract, signed in 2023, was controversial even before its plan to "buy our way in" to the NHS was revealed.

Although the data platform has been more successful than previous attempts to de-silo the NHS, like care.data, it is still not widely adopted and has attracted criticism from healthcare staff.

"The NHS colleagues that are still trying to build benefit from this solution, seem, in the large to be struggling," the former NHS CIO told us.

"Solutions to problems that the Data Platform was trying to fix for should always start with the problem, the people and the process. Never the technology, the most senior relationship, or even the price."

Criticisms mount over Palantir contract extension

Last month more than 40,000 people filed legal objections to having their data included on the FDP because of Palantir's involvement.

They are not alone. Politicians and campaign groups like Amnesty International this week criticised the government's decision to extend the Palantir agreement by another two years, taking the contract to March 2029.

Dame Chi Onwurah, chair of the Commons Science and Technology Committee, said she was "extremely disappointed" in the decision, while Liberal Democrat MP Martin Wrigley accused the government of "kicking the can down the road."

Charlene Pink of Good Law Project was more blunt. She said the government should "stop drinking the Silicon Valley Kool-Aid and start investing in home-grown, open-source alternatives that put people first."

Search begins for Palantir replacement

There is a reason behind the controversial extension. The government says the additional two years are necessary so UK firms can work together on an alternative.

The Department for Health and Social Care says it will begin inviting UK companies to bid to be part of the Palantir replacement.

James Frith, parliamentary under-secretary of state in DHSC, said, “A process this important must command public trust as well as clinical confidence."

He added, "Given the requirement for a new iteration, given performance and the benefits already in play, and given the opportunity to add new capability, including maternity services, to a next generation of [the] FDP, an 18 to 24-month period for commission and procurement is a reasonable assessment."

Frith said "interoperability, resilience, and trusted common standards" should be "baked into" the next generation of the FDP.

Although the news will be welcomed by campaign groups and some NHS staff, the former healthcare CIO talking to us sounded a note of caution:

"As technology professionals, I am sure every member of the NHS team is now slightly celebrating - but also wondering what they do for the next few years whilst this is unravelled.”