Live facial recognition trial expands to London Underground
Campaigners warn of 'dystopian' surveillance
British Transport Police (BTP) is expanding its live facial recognition trial to London Underground stations.
Victoria will be the first Tube station where the cameras are deployed. They will then move between Underground and Network Rail stations before the trial ends in November.
The trial started at London Bridge railway station in February and aims to assess how effectively live facial recognition (LFR) works in a busy transport environment.
A LFR system scans faces captured by cameras and compares them with images on a police watchlist. When the system detects a possible match, an alert is sent to an officer, who must assess the image before deciding whether further action is necessary.
The system uses NEC's NeoFace M40 algorithm, which is also understood to be used by several other police forces.
Chief Superintendent Chris Casey, BTP's senior officer overseeing the project, said extending the trial to Underground stations would allow the force to test the technology in a different transport environment.
The deployments would be "intelligence-led", he said, with the aim of identifying people wanted by police or courts, including suspects in serious offences.
BTP said images of people who did not match its authorised watchlist would be deleted immediately and permanently.
The Underground carries more than 3.7 million passenger journeys on an average weekday, meaning the trial could expose the technology to a large number of members of the public who are not suspected of any crime.
Campaigners warn of 'dystopian' surveillance
Civil liberties groups have criticised the expansion, arguing that LFR effectively turns ordinary public spaces into areas of mass surveillance.
Silkie Carlo, director of Big Brother Watch, described the move as a "disturbing and dystopian expansion" of the technology. She argued that police were moving towards routine use of facial recognition rather than limiting it to exceptional circumstances.
There are also concerns about the possibility of false matches. Critics say innocent people have previously been mistaken for suspects and detained, while people from some ethnic minority groups may face a greater risk of misidentification by facial recognition systems.
Met plans further London deployments
The BTP expansion comes as the Metropolitan Police also prepares to increase its use of LFR technology in London.
The Met has said it plans to introduce the technology in the West End by Christmas, following a six-month pilot in Croydon. It is also expected to deploy the technology in six further areas next year. London's Oxford Street is understood to be among the locations being considered.
Unlike some previous trials using temporary police vehicles, cameras for the planned deployments could be permanently attached to street furniture.
Ruth Ehrlich, of human rights organisation Liberty, said using LFR on Oxford Street would represent a "significant expansion of surveillance in public spaces".
She said the technology scanned the faces of everyone passing through an area, regardless of whether they were suspected of wrongdoing.
Ms Ehrlich called for greater transparency over how the systems would operate and what safeguards would be used to protect people's rights.
She also urged the Met to wait for the government's planned legal framework covering the use of facial recognition by law enforcement before carrying out further deployments.