Google loses final appeal against €4.1bn Android competition penalty
Top EU court backs antitrust penalty
Google has lost its final appeal against a EU antitrust penalty, with Europe's highest court upholding a €4.1 billion fine over the way the company used its Android mobile operating system to strengthen the dominance of its search engine.
The ruling [pdf] by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) confirms an earlier judgment that found the US technology giant had abused its dominant market position through agreements tied to Android devices.
The European Commission first imposed the record-breaking penalty in 2018, accusing Google of using restrictive contractual arrangements to cement the position of Google Search and its Chrome browser on smartphones.
Regulators had originally imposed a €4.3 billion fine on Google, although a lower court later reduced the penalty to €4.1 billion.
The company subsequently appealed to the Europe's highest court, which on Thursday upheld the revised fine, backing the EU regulators' findings.
In its judgment, the court confirmed that Google Search had abused its dominant position through the Android ecosystem. Judges also upheld findings that Android agreements requiring the pre-installation of Google's services had produced anticompetitive effects.
The fine remains the largest competition penalty ever imposed on Google by the European Commission.
Google disagrees with the ruling
Google said it disagreed with the judgment, arguing that Android has expanded consumer choice rather than restricted it.
"Android provides more choice for everyone and supports thousands of businesses," a company spokesperson said.
"This judgment fails to recognise our significant investment to ensure Android remains open, interoperable and free."
The company added that it had already modified its commercial agreements following the Commission's original 2018 decision and remained committed to innovation, openness and supporting developers, partners and users.
Consumer groups welcomed the judgment.
The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) said the decision sent a clear signal that dominant technology companies could not use their market power to restrict competition or limit consumer choice.
BEUC argued that pre-installed applications and restrictive commercial agreements made it significantly harder for consumers to switch to alternative search engines and browsers, reinforcing users' tendency to stick with default options.
BEUC Director General, Agustín Reyna, said Android users had for years been steered towards Google's search engine and Chrome browser, leaving limited opportunities for competitors offering more innovative products or stronger privacy protections to gain market share.
He called on European regulators to move more quickly in tackling the influence of major technology companies and creating fairer conditions for smaller competitors.
Tensions between Brussels and Washington
The decision is likely to intensify tensions between Brussels and Washington.
US President Donald Trump has repeatedly accused the EU of disproportionately targeting American technology companies.
Last week, he threatened to impose 100% tariffs on EU countries that introduce digital services taxes affecting US firms.
The White House also recently announced visa bans on five European public figures, alleging they had unfairly targeted American businesses operating in Europe.
Regulatory scrutiny in Europe
The latest ruling adds to a series of competition defeats for Google in Europe.
In September 2024, EU judges upheld a €2.4 billion fine relating to Google's shopping comparison service.
A year later, the company was fined a further €2.95 billion after regulators concluded it had unfairly favoured its own online advertising products over those of competitors.
Google continues to face further regulatory scrutiny in Europe under the EU's Digital Markets Act.
Ongoing investigations include allegations that the company gives preferential treatment to its own services in search results and imposes restrictions affecting developers seeking to direct users to alternative purchasing options outside the Google Play ecosystem.