MPs accuse Big Tech of ‘complacency’ over online harms
Safeguards are not working, committee says
Meta, X, TikTok and Google were accused of complacency in the face of threats to children, women, democracy and society by a committee of MPs during a combative grilling on Tuesday.
Chairing the Science, Innovation and Technology Committee session on social media, misinformation and harmful algorithms, Chi Onwurah MP said there were concerns over the governance of social media and search platforms, the amount of control individuals have over the algorithms, and a lack of future-proofing of protections.
“The basic fact is, all the work that you tell us you are doing on online harms and to make your platforms safe in this country is not working,” she said as the session drew to a close.
The Big Tech representatives had been quizzed on how they address the worsening problem of misinformation and disinformation. They answered questions on AI-generated fake content, bots, child safety, transparency, accountability and political bias, and in each case were found wanting.
‘Fanning the embers of disinformation’
On disinformation, Martin Wrigley MP told the big tech representatives: "What you're doing isn't working, because the problem is getting worse. You are continuing to fan the embers of misinformation and disinformation, and sometimes you'll send the fire brigade when that fire gets too big.”
He asked what they could do differently going forwards. Inevitably, at a time when some social media companies are cutting fact checkers and safety teams, the answer was more AI.
Failure to protect children
Emily Darlington MP referred to reports showing a 14% increase in AI‑generated child sexual abuse images and a 260‑fold rise in AI‑generated abuse videos in 2025, accusing the platforms of failing to protect children.
“What further action are you going to each take to stop this from happening in the future? Because quite clearly, your policies currently are failing.”
Wifredo Fernandez, X's director of global government affairs, said the platform has “zero tolerance” for such material and is “continuing to strengthen our capabilities and strengthen the technology and our guardrails”. He also claimed that Grok AI had stopped creating nudified images.
Rebecca Stimson, Meta’s UK director of public policy, said its AI is trained not to produce nude images, adding that Meta is working on watermarking technologies.
TikTok's director of public policy for northern Europe, Alistair Law, said technologies to identify and block this material before it is published are improving and that the short video platform doesn’t allow pornography, nudity or harassment. However, Freddy Van Mierlo MP said he’d found instructional videos on how to nudify women on TikTok that very day.
A question about why the platforms are keen to attract children, given that they claim to make very little revenue from them, met with an uncomfortable silence, followed by some hand-wavy comments about “bolstering community” and “engaging with the world”. Were they being altruistic? Samantha Niblett MP interjected. Another pause. “Clearly, it's in our interest to attract users to our service,” Stimson conceded.
More obfuscation was in evidence when the representatives were asked about the outsized influence of their CEOs in the policies and politics of the platforms. Fernandez tried hard not to mention Elon Musk - who has used X to endorse the Restore party in the UK and the AFD in Germany - by name. X is “politically agnostic in our operation and our mission and in our ethos,” he claimed to audible scepticism from the room. “We don't have a political perspective as a platform.”
Disrupting democracy
Conservative MP George Freeman complained that a deepfake video of him crossing the floor to join Reform UK - which he described as a “major disruptive democratic moment” - was still widely available on social media despite requests to have it removed.
Zoe Darmé, Google’s director of trust strategy, said that if content is “violative” it will be detected and removed from YouTube, and individuals can request that damaging content be taken down.
“It's not working because it's still on YouTube,” Freeman replied.
A lack of redress
While it can be difficult to get harmful content taken down, sometimes accounts are closed without explanation, said Niblett. She mentioned the case of a constituent who owns a diner that had its Facebook page, which had 32,000 followers, taken down without warning, apparently for “violating community standards”. She was unable to reach a human operator to ask why. In the meantime she was losing business.
“So I stepped in, and it's only because I know a couple of people at Meta that I'm able to plead for help, but I'm still being told this might take a while.”
More regulation incoming?
Wrigley raised the prospect that social media platforms should be regulated in the same way as other media. “Your algorithms and recommended content and your publication of content is curation, which, in my view, turns you into publishers,” he said.
Certainly the MPs were in no mood for compromise.
Wrapping up the session, Onwurah said: “The committee feels quite strongly that there is a level of complacency in your responses to our questions and in the evidence that you are giving.”
The session took place against a backdrop of the government weighing a ban on social media for under-16s. Meanwhile X is under investigation for Grok AI’s generation of non-consensual sexualised images; and on Tuesday Meta was fined $375 million by a US court for misleading users over the safety of its platforms for children.