EU Court rules against Commission in Meta, TikTok fee dispute
Brussels ordered to redraft tech fee rules
Meta and TikTok have secured a major victory against the European Commission over how the bloc charges Big Tech companies to fund enforcement of its sweeping Digital Services Act (DSA).
The General Court at the Court of Justice of the European Union has found in favour of Meta and TikTok, finding fault with the Commission's method for calculating annual "supervisory fees" imposed on very large online platforms.
These fees, which are proportionate to user numbers and company profits, are intended to cover the Commission's costs of overseeing compliance with the DSA.
At the heart of the dispute was how the Commission measured user bases. Under the law, platforms with more than 45 million average monthly active users in the EU fall under direct Commission supervision.
Meta and TikTok argued that Brussels used a flawed methodology to determine user counts, resulting in disproportionate fees.
The judges agreed that the Commission had erred procedurally by relying on an internal methodology attached to individual decisions, rather than adopting a formal delegated act – a legal step required under the DSA.
"In order to determine the amount of the supervisory fee payable for 2023, the Commission calculated the number of average monthly active recipients of the services concerned on the basis of a common methodology based on data provided by third-party operators and annexed to each implementing decision," the court wrote [pdf].
"However, since that methodology is an essential and indispensable element of the determination of the supervisory fee, it should have been adopted not in the context of implementing decisions but in a delegated act."
The court stopped short of ordering regulators to reimburse the companies for the fees already paid, leaving the current payments intact while the Commission drafts a new legal framework.
Judges gave the EU executive one year to codify its approach to calculating users and adopt new implementing decisions.
The European Commission downplayed the defeat, stating that the ruling was procedural rather than substantive.
"The Court confirms our methodology is sound: no error in calculation, no suspension of any payments, no problem with the principle of the fee nor the amount," a Commission spokesperson said.
Meta, however, said the judgment would force regulators to confront what it sees as inequities in the current system.
"Currently, companies that record a loss don't have to pay, even if they have a large user base or represent a greater regulatory burden, leaving others to pay a larger and disproportionate amount of the total," the company said.
"We look forward to the flaws in the methodology being addressed."
TikTok also welcomed the ruling, saying it would closely monitor the Commission's next steps.
The supervisory fee is one of the funding mechanisms underpinning the DSA, which came into force in November 2022.
The law requires "very large online platforms" to act against illegal and harmful content or face fines of up to 6% of their annual global turnover. It applies not only to Meta and TikTok, but also to Apple, Amazon, Booking.com, Google, Microsoft, Elon Musk's X, Snapchat, and Pinterest.