Google AI Overviews make users almost half as likely to click on links, research says
Search-based advertising revenues continue decline
Pew Research Centre confirms that Google’s AI Overview feature is reducing visitor traffic and depressing ad revenue
Google’s AI Overviews significantly reduce the likelihood of users clicking through to websites, research published earlier this week from Pew Research Centre confirms.
900 US users who agreed to share their web browsing activity with researchers indicated that the AI Overviews which Google introduced last year, had a significant effect on their browsing habits.
Specifically, users who were presented with an AI Summary following a search, which happens in around 20% of searches, went on to click a traditional search result in 8% of all visits. Those who did not get the AI Summary clicked on a search result in 15% of queries.
If a Google user encountered a link embedded in the Overview itself, they were vanishingly unlikely to click on it – this occurred in just 1% of visits to pages with such a summary.
Pew’s research also found that the presence of an overview made web users more likely to close their session there and then. 26% of pages topped with an AI summary were closed straight away, compared to 16% of pages that were not summarised.
The findings from the non-profit Pew Research Centre compound those reported earlier this year from AI analytics company BrightEdge, which reported that the Google AI Overviews had dropped click throughs by 30%, although it had generated more search impressions, so Google is just fine.
Less fine, is the wider web business ecosystem which is built on search referrals. There has been much discussion on the extent to which alternative business models are viable.
Earlier this month, Cloudflare CEO Mathew Prince announced in a blog post that Cloudflare would block AI crawlers by default, to prevent the “the web being stripmined by AI crawlers with content creators seeing almost no traffic and therefore almost no value.”
Prince argued that Google has essentially reneged on the deal it made with content creators decades ago, that deal being that it would send visitors to those websites if it could access and index them.
Web users should also be aware of the dangers of relying on AI Overviews, given the track record the feature has of producing incorrect or misleading information. Earlier this year, the feature was subjected to trolling from people who realised that you could type a wholly concocted, ridiculous idiom into Google, follow it with the word ‘meaning’ and have Google AI Overview produce a plausible and confident explanation of its origin, sometimes citing completely made-up sources.