European leaders make wooly promises about digital sovereignty
But stop short of limiting US hyperscalers
Europe’s sweeping new strategy sets targets for its digital ambitions, but leaves the path to get there unclear.
European leaders have set out a new International Digital Strategy (IDS) to both boost digital competitiveness and deepen relationships with external partner countries. However, there is debate about who those partners are today.
Henna Virkkunen, EVP for Tech Sovereignty, Security and Democracy, said in a speech in Brussels, "We are living through a profound digital revolution that is reshaping economies and societies worldwide. This is happening in a geopolitical landscape that is more challenging than before.”
The thinly veiled reference to Donald Trump’s tumultuous US leadership continued, as Virkunnen said the EU “is stepping forward as a stable and reliable partner, deeply committed to digital cooperation with our allies and partners.”
That might reassure stakeholders who see the USA as an unreliable ally in the wake of Trump’s victory and controversial second term, which has included a massive shakeup over tariffs, slapdash use of AI in important trade calculations and multiple cybersecurity incidents.
US cloud giants like Google, Microsoft and AWS have stepped in to reassure European customers that their data is safe, although those reassurances have yet to be tested.
One of the IDS’ stated goals is to “expand international partnerships by deepening existing Digital Partnerships and Dialogues, establishing new ones, and fostering collaboration through a new Digital Partnership Network.” This has led to questions about whether the EU still considers the USA as one of those partners.
Virkunnen told journalists, "When it comes to [the] USA, of course, [the] USA has been our most important strategic partner when it comes to security and economics for a long time, and we know that USA tech companies, of course, they are playing a very important role in our economy and in our society in the European Union.”
She notably did not name the USA as a partner the EU had engaged with recently, instead highlighting Japan, Korea, Singapore and Canada.
Europe’s newly announced strategy is more about ambition than practicality. It sets out the EU’s aspirations for how to engage with allies and talks about a swath of technologies that include such as AI, 5G/6G, semiconductors, quantum technologies, cybersecurity and digital identities, but contains no firm commitments.
The EU seems to have missed the mark in failing to tackle concerns. Its release coming as tech groups are calling for radical action on digital sovereignty, and some companies are even exploring divesting themselves of US tech entirely.
Mark Boost, CEO of UK-based sovereign cloud provider Civo, told Computing that the Strategy “reads less like a roadmap for sovereignty and more like a white flag.” He added that it “sends a clear message about the scale and power of the hyperscale lobby in Europe.”
“Sovereignty means setting the terms of engagement; not letting them be dictated to you. The EU must stop measuring success by access to foreign innovation and start backing local ecosystems that can collaborate globally.”