• Home
  • News
  • Big Data & Analytics
  • DevOps
  • Security
  • GDPR
  • AI & ML
  • Women in Tech
  • Cloud & Infrastructure
  • CIO
  • Deskflix
  • Events
  • Whitepapers
  • Spotlights
  • IT Leaders 250
  • Research
  • Delta
  • Tech Marketing Hub
  • About Us
  • Newsletters
  • Sign in
  •  
      • Newsletters
      • Account details
      • Contact support
      • Sign out
     
     
    • You are currently accessing Computing via your Enterprise account.

      If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

      If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

      Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

      Email: customerservices@incisivemedia.com

      • Sign in
     
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Newsletters
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Register
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
      event logo
      Good listeners: Why conversational interfaces are now a must-have

      This webinar, featuring dedicated research, will explore how conversational interfaces can add value to your digital initiatives today. We discuss the benefits of putting the AI to work and the value of the conversational channel itself.

      • Date: 17 Mar 2021
      • Virtual Event,
      event logo
      Deskflix IT Leader's Summit

      Six months on from our inaugural IT Leaders’ Festival, Deskflix IT Leaders’ Summit is a chance to take stock and reflect on the first quarter of 2021. How did you overcome the obstacles of 2020? Was progression as expected? What were your biggest threats and biggest growth opportunities?

      • Date: 24 Mar 2021
      event logo
      Architect for the unknown: Is your database built for a crisis?

      This webinar, in which we’ll reveal Computing’s latest research in this area, reflects on how prepared our respondents’ data architecture was going into the pandemic and the role databases have to play in the ability to react and pivot in a crisis.

      • Date: 25 Mar 2021
      event logo
      AI & Machine Learning Awards 2021

      The Computing AI & Machine Learning Awards recognise the best companies, individuals, and projects in the AI space today. The awards cover every corner of the industry: security, ethics, data analysis, innovation and more, as well as showcasing the movers and shakers: the technology heroes and projects that deserve industry-wide praise. The winners will be announced in London on 1 July 2020. Entries are now open!

      • Date: 09 Jun 2021
      • TBC, London
      View all events
  • Whitepapers
    • LATEST WHITEPAPERS
      Darktrace 120x194
      Cyber AI Response: Threat Report 2019

      This white paper details 7 case studies of attacks that were intercepted and neutralised by Darktrace cyber defense AI, including a zero-day trojan in a manufacturing company's network. Learn how Darktrace Antigena AI Response modules fight back autonomously, no matter where a threat may emerge, extending to the Cloud, Email and SaaS.

      Download
      Darktrace 120x194
      Cyber AI & Darktrace Cloud

      This white paper explores how cloud is a security blind spot for many organisations who struggle with the limited visibility and control in this new environment, where their existing security tools are often not applicable.

      Download
      Find whitepapers
      Search by title or subject area
      View all whitepapers
  • Spotlights
    • Spotlights

      Welcome to Computing's Spotlight section, where we focus in on particularly important themes and topics of enterprise IT.

      Intel logo

       

      Endpoint Management and Security Hub

  • IT Leaders 250
  • Research
  • Delta
  • Tech Marketing Hub
  • About Us
Computing
Computing
  • Home
  • News
  • Big Data & Analytics
  • DevOps
  • Security
  • GDPR
  • AI & ML
  • Women in Tech
  • Cloud & Infrastructure
  • CIO
  • Deskflix
 
    • Newsletters
    • Account details
    • Contact support
    • Sign out
 
 
  • You are currently accessing Computing via your Enterprise account.

    If you already have an account please use the link below to sign in.

    If you have any problems with your access or would like to request an individual access account please contact our customer service team.

    Phone: +44 (0) 1858 438800

    Email: customerservices@incisivemedia.com

    • Sign in
 
  • Applications

Lo and Behold: Werner Herzog on why he saw the internet as 'a whole new continent' he needed to explore

Computing goes to Sundance and sits down with the director of the most radical film yet made about the connected world

Lo and Behold: Werner Herzog on why he saw the internet as 'a whole new continent' he needed to explore
  • Peter Gothard
  • Peter Gothard
  • @petergothard
  • 27 January 2016
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
0 Comments

Werner Herzog is a film director who needs little introduction, at least to anybody who knows films. From the despair of Aguirre: The Wrath of God, in which a band of conquistadors try - and utterly fail - to tame the Amazon and discover El Dorado, to Grizzly Man, a punishing documentary about one man's passion for fierce creatures outweighing his survival instinct, Herzog has made a career of charting journeys into the unknown.

Famous for not owning a mobile phone - he made his first telephone call at the ripe old age of 17 - Herzog is a self-confessed beginner when it comes to the world of the internet, and to connectivity.

Nevertheless, application and network performance management firm NetScout, who you may remember is currently in an unprecedented legal battle with analyst house Gartner, decided to strike out with another IT industry first and hire Herzog to create a documentary about the internet called Lo and Behold: Reveries of a Connected World.

Computing attended the premier at the Sundance Film Festival in Utah this week, and discovered a film unafraid to ask questions about the hyperconnected future we're currently throwing ourselves headlong into.

With interview subjects that range from scientists at Stamford University who are building football-playing robots they hope can replace human players, to a group of people living beneath America's largest telescope, who in order to allow it to function have withdrawn from the world of electronic communications altogether, the film asks more questions than it answers, and does so through the filter of a self-confessed "curious man" who has been probing minds in a career spanning 50 years.

"A very deep question, with no full answers"

Herzog considers the film to be only the beginning of a dialogue that is set to continue. In this spirit, Computing sat down with Herzog and NetScout CMO Jim McNiel to discuss the film's message.

Herzog calls his film "a deep, conceptual look into the phenomenon of the connected world".

"Because [the internet] is not just a technical device. [The film is about] how we, as human beings, are in contact with other human beings, and how this information, or teaching, or memory, or social interaction, is being redefined, and [asking] how do we respond as human beings to all these things coming at us?

"And sometimes that's a very deep question with no full answers from anyone," he says.

In the film Herzog, referencing Prussian war theorist Carl von Clausewitz's question "Does war dream of itself?", asks whether the internet, in fact, dreams of itself also.

McNiel, who clearly sees Herzog's film as a mesmerising adjunct to NetScout's "Guardians of the Connected World" campaign, says working with Herzog has changed the way he sees the internet.

"There's one thing that surprised me about this process," McNiel tells Computing.

"I'm a technology guy, and I've been in technology for years, and I thought this was going to be a film about technology, and the impact technology has on society.

"But it turns out it's not a film about technology at all - it's a film about humanity. And that was the big surprise for me - because really we are the creators of the connected world, and it's created in our image: which is why it has viruses, and failures and foibles, and why it commits crime. Because it's a mirror of all of humanity. That was where the film took me."

For Herzog - perhaps harking back to the characters in Aguirre: Wrath of God, cast adrift on a raft and left for dead - having now experienced the internet, he can see it as nothing more than a vast and alternately inspiring and bewildering space. As research in cloud computing, the Internet of Things, embeddables and advanced AI begin to accelerate to levels way beyond our control, it's getting easier to share his outlook.

"It's like seeing a new continent," he says.

"You can say, ‘Oh look, there's something there: ice floes and cold water on a whole continent, Antarctica is materialising. And you just take a few dogs and a sledge and food and you start to explore. It's unknown terrain, and for the next 10, 20, 30 or 50 years we'll continue to navigate and move into very, very uncharted terrain.

"There's lots of terra incognita out there, and I'm really fascinated - I like these voyages where you do not know exactly where it's going to take you. It's not like tomorrow I'm flying from Salt Lake City to Burbank and I know the number of the plane and the arrival time, and I know the airport at Burbank. This voyage into the unknown is fascinating. And not just for me, of course. Many people are much more internet-literate [than me], but there's so much unknown terrain out there that is going to come at us and we've no clue what is coming."

"A computer is not going to make a film as good as mine"

Herzog has been scathing about AI's potential to mimic, or certainly collaborate, with humanity. In the press conference before our interview, he said a machine couldn't make a film as good as his within "4,500 years".

The figure, of course, was plucked out of thin air, but after what he saw making Lo and Behold, how can he be so sure?

"Of course I'm sure," he snaps.

"The same way I'm sure that nobody among my film maker colleagues could make a film on the internet as good as I do. I just know it. When you're looking around here now, you don't know what's going to happen in ten thousand years, it's too vague. But there are certain things I know: a computer is not going to make a film as good as mine."

McNiel, however, says that when AI begins to move from so-called general intelligence to super intelligence "there's the possibility that something like that may happen".

"Look at the quality of entertainment that's consumed en masse - can a computer produce that stuff? More than likely," he smiles.

"But a computer will never create the kind of tragic humour of Buster Keaton," Herzog chimes in.

"Forget about any capacity of computers - Buster Keaton will never be paralleled by another human being, nor by a computer."

McNiel agrees, citing an ongoing project to create an AI comedian: "It can write jokes, and you may laugh at a few of them, but it's almost like they're being knocked together by a 12 year old. They've just taken irony and opposition, and they're trying to mathematically construct humour.

"There's the thing that's going to be always different: a computer just follows a formula," he says.

"Snowden was right"

Herzog has interesting views on the data privacy debate and the impact of whistleblower Edward Snowden's NSA revelations.

"We do know all those flows of gigantic data can be tapped into, and of course it's a question of public interest versus privacy and of course the debate is not over.

"I always had the feeling that, yes, somebody was watching what I'm doing," he says, adding that this inspired him to do a little test in which he performed several Google searches in the space of a week for Harley Davidson motorbikes he didn't want.

"All of a sudden, I'm flooded by ads from Harley Davidson repair shops, and with that I know that somebody, some algorithm, knows what I'm trying to find," he says.

"I do not need Snowden [to know all that], but now we know more precisely and more about the entire infrastructure. But there is surveillance and we know that."

Herzog, like many others, always sticks a piece of plastic over any built-in laptop camera.

But did Snowden do the right thing by speaking out?

"I think so, I think so," replies Herzog.

"Although of course there's the question of national security, but it's not really jeopardised by [speaking out about this]."

"There's never an excuse to let national government jeopardise freedom," says McNiel.

"He did the right thing because he knew the government was breaking the law. If they want to protect the people of this country then do so by all means - I'm sure they had our best interests at heart - but they need to go back and look at the legislation."

For Herzog, however, there's another glaring injustice here:

"I ask myself: the head of the NSA was in a congressional hearing, and he lies to Congress - clearly he lies - and after they've sworn him in."

"Yeah, it's perjury," says McNiel.

"Perjury, yes," replies Herzog.

"But on a very high level. You just don't lie to Congress or a Senate hearing. If you do that, before you even walk out of the door there will be federal marshals who arrest you.

"So now I ask: has the NSA boss been taken in by marshals? In which prison is he languishing? What sort of trial has he had to stand? Did he answer in court? Who arrested him? Tell me who arrested him."

The answer, of course, is nobody. And that's perhaps one of the only succinct and definite answers available as Herzog continues to tussle with even starting to make sense of the connected world, its effects on humanity, and how it will continue to shape and grow either with our guidance, or entirely on its own.

If and when Lo and Behold finds a distributor for mainstream release, Computing highly recommends it. An offbeat and utterly unique insight into a world we, in our industry, are immersed in on a daily basis, it's an excellent opportunity to begin some essential self-examination.

Further reading

Why we must all be guardians of the connected world
  • Software
  • 30 October 2015
Court allows NetScout accusation of Gartner Magic Quadrant "pay for play" business model to continue
  • Business Software
  • 17 December 2015
Gartner Magic Quadrant 'pay for play': 'We don't know the result until we see the report' says SAP after fifth year at the top
  • Applications
  • 23 December 2015
  • Tweet  
  • Facebook  
  • LinkedIn  
  • Send to  
  • Topics
  • Applications
  • Internet
  • Mobile
  • Wireless
  • Werner Herzog
  • Lo and Behold
  • NetScout
  • NetScout vs Gartner
  • Jim McNiel
  • connected devices
  • internet
  • Internet of Things
  • Web
  • Darknet
  • Cyber security
  • Edward Snowden
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • machine learning
  • NetscoutCollaboration

More on Applications

Working from home: Why 20 percent of managers see the world wrongly

  • Internet
  • 22 February 2021
We need to forge a radical path to 6G
Peter Cochrane: We need to forge a radical path to 6G

5G is way too inefficient for the IoT, argues Peter Cochrane

  • Networks
  • 16 February 2021
Exclusive research: Computing uncovers your mobility must-haves and priorities for managing the remote working boom

  • Mobile
  • 03 February 2021
Researchers demonstrate wireless transmission of UltraHD 8K video using terahertz waves
6G one step closer with wireless transmission of UltraHD 8K video using terahertz waves

Terahertz waves can transmit more information in less time

  • Wireless
  • 03 February 2021
Citizens Advice: Broadband prices lock poorest UK households out of key services
Citizens Advice: Broadband prices lock poorest UK households out of key services

About 2.3 million people had fallen behind on their broadband bill towards the end of 2020

  • Internet
  • 29 January 2021
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to Top

Most read

Microsoft announces passwordless authentication in Azure and updates to Teams and Outlook
Microsoft announces passwordless authentication in Azure and updates to Teams and Outlook
Critical vulnerability found in Snow Software's Inventory Agent
Critical vulnerability found in Snow Software's Inventory Agent
SolarWinds executives blame intern for 'solarwinds123' password lapse
SolarWinds executives blame intern for 'solarwinds123' password lapse
Facebook ordered to pay $650m to settle facial recognition lawsuit
Facebook ordered to pay $650m to settle facial recognition lawsuit
Oxford University confirms breach of its Covid-19 lab
Oxford University confirms breach of its Covid-19 lab
  • Contact
  • Delta
  • Marketing solutions
  • Enterprise IT Events
  • Incisive Media
  • Terms & conditions
  • Policies
  • Careers
  • Privacy Settings
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Newsletters
  • Facebook
  • YouTube

im_logo

© Incisive Business Media (IP) Limited, Published by Incisive Business Media Limited, New London House, 172 Drury Lane, London WC2B 5QR, registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09177174 & 09178013

Digital publisher of the year
Digital publisher of the year 2010, 2013, 2016 & 2017
Loading