Les Hatton

BBC’s Panorama panders to the ignorant

The current affairs programme’s recent Wi-Fi “exposé” was scare-mongering drivel of the crassest kind

Written by Les Hatton

Many readers may be feeling that they need to wear tin-foil hats following the recent BBC Panorama “exposé” of Wi-Fi and the supposedly harmful effects on the brains of children caused by installing wireless networks in schools. All I can say in reassurance is that this sort of mathematically dysfunctional, scare-mongering drivel really makes me cross.

The programme started off by shooting itself in the foot when it admitted that half of the reported experiments showed an effect and the other half didn’t. However, the presenters bravely soldiered on with the disdain for statistical concepts that has become customary in recent years. The only person on the programme who knew what he was talking about was a World Health Organisation (WHO) scientist, who patiently tried to explain the science. This was too much for the reporter, who tried to discredit the WHO scientist by pointing to his associations with industry, although it seemed a far greater crime was daring to disagree with the programme.

This is how this sort of nonsense works. Suppose I am a Panorama reporter and I believe that the tossing of coins is influenced by the presence of invisible UFOs. I arrange for 1,000 reputable scientists around the world to toss a coin 100 times each. If heads turns up more than 60 times, then I will assert that there is an obvious effect due to the UFOs; 3/5 sounds perfectly convincing. The probability of this happening by chance is about 0.0287. In other words, if 1,000 people do this, then on average about 29 people will report more than 60 heads, and one of them may report 70 heads or more.

Then in a masterstroke, I interview three of the 29 who will report an effect, and I can build up a story that the government really should do something about invisible UFOs. To provide balance, I will also interview one scientist who didn’t note the effect, but I will accuse him or her of being an alien.

In the Wi-Fi programme, Panorama asserted that Wi-Fi in schools posed a risk to children. The fact that the WHO has found no statistically significant evidence to support this claim cut no ice with our Panorama reporter, who no doubt is now working on a programme to implicate fairies in house subsidence.

My book of the month is Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and its Consequences by John Allen Paulos, a real mathematician. I suggest the Panorama team read it before inflicting any more of this nonsense on us.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print this
  • Share

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

City of London

City of London goes Wi-Fi

Financial centre to become Europe's biggest hotspot 16 Apr 2007

 

Demand for Wi-Fi mobiles to explode

Dual-mode handsets set for take off this year, reports In-Stat 04 Jun 2007

Are the Wi-Fi-anxious away with the fairies?

There is more than a whiff of mysticism in the current scare over WLAN radiation 29 May 2007

Wi-Fi health risks are clouded by static

Finding statistics to evaluate the health dangers of wireless networks will not be an easy task 15 May 2007

related white papers

today's top stories

Apple overhauls iPod Shuffle, Nano and Touch

New models come with iTunes update and social networking tool 02 Sep 2010

Scottish school shifts wholly to the iPad

Head of computing and IT at Cedars School gives the rationale behind his decision 01 Sep 2010

Salford's MediaCity pushes technology boundaries

In preperation for 3D, ultra HD and a tapeless workflow 02 Sep 2010

Google adds Priority Inbox to combat information overload

Gmail feature will "revolutionise the way we use email" 31 Aug 2010

Cost of Windows 7 migration will rise due to lack of skilled staff

As the deadline for moving to Windows 7 approaches, businesses will have to dig deep to keep their operating systems up-to-date 27 Aug 2010

Advertisement

Power and cooling management for the data centre
The principles for achieving power and cooling capacity management in the modern data centre

The value of virtual infrastructures to business continuity
This IDC paper examines the role of server and storage virtualisation in enabling application and data continuity at a lower overall cost

Advertisement

Citrix

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; IThound.com brings you thousands of white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

How open are you to mobile banking via a smartphone?

How open are you to mobile banking via a smartphone?

In what capacity would you use your smartphone for mobile banking?

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

A microphoneAudio

Computing Podcast: Tech Talk episode 5

Join Tech Talk for an overview of the week's top IT stories, and a debate on IT self-service. Will it provide value? 27 Aug 2010

A microphoneAudio

Computing podcast: Tech Talk episode 4

Join Tech Talk for an overview of the week's top IT stories, and a debate on IT skills. Is the UK slipping behind? 20 Aug 2010

Latest in-depth articles

picture of a TV studioAnalysis

Salford's MediaCity pushes technology boundaries

In preperation for 3D, ultra HD and a tapeless workflow 02 Sep 2010

Second Life avatarAnalysis

What are the business benefits of virtual worlds?

Experts cite collaboration and brainstorming, recruitment and training 26 Aug 2010

Primary Navigation