Even the best security needs a plan B

The most important part of building digital defences is knowing how to avert disaster when they fail

Written by Phil Muncaster

Japanese trains are useless, really useless. Don't believe the stereotype - sleek, elegant machines gliding effortlessly at hundreds of miles an hour, with the snow-capped Mount Fuji towering imperiously behind. They're actually hopelessly inefficient and unreliable.

Actually, that's complete nonsense. I've travelled the length and breadth of the archipelago while cocooned inside these perfectly engineered machines and have only once had cause for complaint, when the on-board vending machine dispensed dried squid instead of Asahi.

Yet this is the kind of vitriol, minus the profanities, you might hear from the man on the Tokyo omnibus in the 0.001 percent of the year that the transport infrastructure fails. Because that's what humans love to do. We put our faith in technology and come to rely on it, only to reel away in disbelief when it fails us: how could it, how dare it fail us? And then we're left exposed, without a plan, stranded on the platform with our trousers round our ankles, so to speak.

The metaphor extends (yes it does, it really does) to software programming. As Marc Maiffret, ex-hacker and co-founder of security firm eEye told me, it takes just four or five programming mistakes in 26 million lines of Windows code for a major threat to appear every four months or so.

So in December last year the Windows Metafile flaw reared its ugly head, and before too long we'll no doubt hear of another threat to enterprise customers. Every time a vulnerability like this comes to light the developers get it in the neck - if only software was written well and tested thoroughly in the first place, the commentators say, we wouldn't have nearly as many security flaws in applications. But it is almost inevitable that mistakes will be made; as good as they are, those human beings doing code analysis will be prone to error, and automated checking tools can only be automated so far.

What this means for IT managers is that even if all the applications running on their networks are engineered to the highest possible standards, a proactive approach to security is still a necessity, not an option. Yet every time a Windows Metafile-type incident comes along there are casualties: those who thought their defences were adequate and failed to install comprehensive end-to-end security.

For many, the difficulty is in keeping up to date with the ever-expanding range of security products on the market. How do you sift out the rubbish, the exaggerated claims and the over-hyped features of many vendors and get to the good stuff?
The CSIA's Claims Tested Mark will certainly be welcomed by IT purchasers as one way to separate wheat from chaff. But many still lack the knowledge to determine whether the kit they choose is really suitable for their specific security requirements.

If they have not done so already, IT departments need to plan now to ensure they have the resources and knowledge necessary to see their way through the maze of products on offer, and understand their limitations, so their systems are as prepared as possible for the unknown.

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

Will corporates outsource security?

The growing range of security threats may force more firms to use outside expertise 16 Sep 2005

 

BP leads security initiative

Achilles Project seeks to block attacks on UK’s critical national infrastructure 21 Sep 2005

HSA strengthens network security

Healthcare firm restricts employee use of USB devices 02 Feb 2006

Cisco upgrades security systems

Updated tools should improve company security 30 Sep 2005

Security is hard work

Implementing effective IT security involves long hours of planning, monitoring and analysis 12 Oct 2005

Security - hardware or software?

New hardware offerings may make security easier but they could leave significant gaps 18 Oct 2005

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Body Shop rolls out PCI system

Retailer hopes to benefit from improved customer data analysis 07 Oct 2008

Where to offshore (and why not here?)

Tholons, the research firm founded by well-known offshoring guru Avinash Vashistha , has just published some new research in Global Services magazine... 07 Oct 2008

The future of Ethernet

Where is Ethernet going? We look at the future of the widely-used networking technology. 07 Oct 2008

The pIT stop Q&A: How can I measure the business success of IT applications?

Ou expert panel answers readers' real-life IT questions 07 Oct 2008

National Identity Fraud Prevention Week

Every Monday seems to mark the beginning of a new awareness drive and this week’s theme has particular importance to small businesses... 06 Oct 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Would you apply for a job that was advertised on Facebook or a similar social networking site?

Would you apply for a job that was advertised on Facebook or a similar social networking site?

The government is using Facebook to recruit IT staff - would you apply to such an ad?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Ethernet cableVideo

The future of Ethernet

Where is Ethernet going? We look at the future of the widely-used networking technology. 07 Oct 2008

Podcast imageAudio

Computing podcast - Next-generation broadband Britain; and we report from Gartner's IT security summit

In our latest podcast, we discuss the hurdles that a national fibre-optic network must overcome, and look at the issues discussed at the recent IT security conference 02 Oct 2008

Latest in-depth articles

credit cardAnalysis

Body Shop rolls out PCI system

Retailer hopes to benefit from improved customer data analysis 07 Oct 2008

Features

How to ensure progress in programming

Best practice advice from Forrester Research 02 Oct 2008

Advertisement

Primary Navigation