Lem Bingley
Lem Bingley

More patent nonsense

For anyone wondering how to get rich quick in IT, the answer is patently obvious

Written by Lem Bingley

As you read this I shall be packing my bags and moving to the US - a country that nurtures talent, rewards innovation and, more importantly, hands out patents like toffees.

My plan to profit from the bleeding obvious formed late last month, after learning that AT&T had filed a lawsuit against eBay.

AT&T asserts that eBay's PayPal service acts as a trusted intermediary, facilitating payments between buyers and sellers over the internet. Not much argument on that point, except that AT&T goes on to argue that it patented the concept in 1994.

The result was US patent number 5,329,589: "Mediation of Transactions by a Communication System". Never mind that Western Union began transferring other people's money by telegraph 132 years ago - AT&T's business method was deemed to be new and non-obvious enough for a patent.

While eBay's lawyers wrestle with AT&T, they must also work on their appeal in another case. In August eBay was ordered to hand $30m to start-up MercExchange after being found guilty of infringing US patent 5,845,265: "A method and apparatus for creating a computerised market for used and collectible goods". MercExchange filed its patent application on 7 November 1995. And eBay was founded to provide, er... a computerised market for used and collectible goods, on 4 September 1995.

And then of course there is the infamous Eolas patent, number 5,838,906, covering the seemingly not very large leap from applications embedded in documents to applications embedded in web pages. Microsoft found itself on the wrong end this patent and lost in court, prompting the W3C to cry foul and the US Patent & Trademark Office to mumble that it would look again at the patent.

We may not be able to patent such things in Europe, but of course that does not mean Europeans are immune to the effects. UK firms that do business in the US must join the game, for example, while the economic viability of UK products can be undermined if they can't be offered in the US without attracting royalties.

Often, patent disputes hinge on proving that a supposed invention actually existed beforehand. This can be tricky if the innovation seems obvious in hindsight. The advice from some patent attorneys is therefore to file claims early and often. It is possible to submit cheap provisional patent applications - incomplete claims that nonetheless prove useful if another party subsequently gains a patent for something you rely on.

Back here, the European Patent Office (EPO) is pondering moves that would expand the usefulness of the patent system. In October it published research showing that many firms are failing to gain benefit from patents in two ways: first by not seeking protection for their own inventions, and secondly for failing to see the patents of others as a source of competitive intelligence.

The EPO report concluded that "most companies have no idea what patent information can do for them" and that the EPO should make patent information easier to use, understand and to access.

So that is the germ of my patent application: a computerised searching system for uncovering market intelligence in patent documentation. Not original, clearly. Obvious? Probably. But neither hurdle seems insurmountable.

And then I'll sue Google.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print this
  • Share

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

Lem Bingley

Europe should not take the soft patent option

Before blindly following the US, the EU should take a hard look at why software patents cause problems 07 Jun 2004

 

Draft EU law is patently daft

If enacted as it stands, the draft directive on software patents could cripple the European IT sector 06 Oct 2003

Double standards on patents

Software giants such as Microsoft often use patents to stifle competition. But they are not averse to exploiting patent-free technologies when it suits them 29 Jul 2003

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Face facts: social media is the future

No organisation can afford to ignore the way business communications are changing 18 Mar 2010

Is the data watchdog about to pounce?

Experts believe the Information Commissioner’s Office is itching to use its new power to impose hefty fines for data breaches. Martin Courtney reports 18 Mar 2010

Lloyd’s of London gears up for regulation

CIO Peter Hambling tells Angelica Mari about how the insurance market has updated its IT infrastructure to comply with new regulations 18 Mar 2010

Protests greet new Digital Economy Bill amendment

ISPs, digital rights groups and Liberal Democrat supporters cry foul 05 Mar 2010

IT Leaders' Forum in association with IBM

A unique opportunity to hear from expert speakers and engage in a debate about the future of the CIO job function 29 Jan 2010

Advertisement

Keys to successful Service‐Oriented Architecture implementation

This white paper explores best practices and general design patterns for service oriented architecture (SOA).

The Roadmap to IT Maturity — Matching Strategy to Infrastructure for Business Success

This paper defines a roadmap for matching infrastructure strategy to business success.

Advertisement

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; ITHound.com brings you over 6,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

NHS centralised data

NHS centralised data

Do you think the NHS can be trusted to safely look after personal data electronically?

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Video

HP unveils S Series notebooks

'Prosumer' line overhauled 01 Mar 2010

Web Seminar Listings

Preparing for enterprise-scale Windows 7 migration

The web seminar on 18 Feb will discuss how Windows 7 migration can increase IT efficiency in large enterprises, freeing up budgetary and personnel resources to focus on business innovation. Our panel of experts will examine the strategies, tools and services IT leaders can use to migrate successfully and reap the rewards of increased efficiency. 19 Feb 2010

Latest in-depth articles

Derek FindlayComment

Hot Seat: Derek Findlay

Derek Findlay is computing support officer at the University of Aberdeen where he works with a team of more than 20 people 18 Mar 2010

David ChanComment

Do we want to play musical chairs?

More attention to training and development would improve IT staff retention and reduce costs 18 Mar 2010

Primary Navigation