HP helps Africa with recycling standards

27 Sep 2007

Comments: 2

A Computing logo
Picture of e-waste mountain
The recycling sector is largely unregulated in African countries

HP is working with international development groups to improve computer recycling practices in four of its fastest-growing African markets.

According to United Nations (UN) estimates, 30 per cent of the world’s obsolete electronics ends up in Africa.

Further reading

The continent must contend with waste shipped in from overseas, much of it illegally, and the output of burgeoning domestic IT sales.

Anecdotal evidence from non-governmental organisations (NGOs) suggests staggering volumes of discarded foreign PCs.

“An estimated 500 containers of used computer scrap enter Nigeria each month,” says a report from the Basel Action Network, a lobby group specialising in e-waste issues.

“We believe the used electronics trade in Nigeria is but one example of what is taking place every day in the ports of developing countries worldwide, and certainly in Africa,” it says.

The domestic IT market is also growing fast, and global hardware firms are seeing hugely increased sales in the more developed African countries.

Recycling is a potentially lucrative industry and most African countries already have an active commercial market.

But, unlike in Europe, the sector is largely unregulated. And fierce competitive pressure can lead to corner-cutting.

In many African countries, regulations need to be strengthened to meet the growing pressure, said HP takeback compliance manager Kirsty Macintyre.

“The amount of IT selling in Africa is increasing and we want to have proper recycling infrastructures in place before it is too late,” she said.

HP will work with two NGOs - ­the Global Digital Solidarity Fund (DSF) and the Swiss Institute for Materials Science and Technology (Empa) -­ to educate recycling firms about the benefits of adhering to environmental best practice.

Schemes in Tunisia, Morocco and Kenya are at an evaluation stage and a programme is already up and running in South Africa.

Once standards have been developed, the partnership will lobby the relevant governments to ensure that they are met across the recycling industry.

“We want to put policies and government representatives in place so that when we withdraw, those policies are self-imposed,” said Macintyre.

A key challenge will be to give the schemes a commercial edge. Foreign agency developments often fail when the lead organisation withdraws. So ensuring the programme is run as a business will encourage participation, said DSF e-waste project manager Cissé Kane.

“We must show people they can make money and create jobs with our schemes,” he said.

The programme should also help meet concerns about the ethics of shipping obsolete electronics abroad.

The UN estimates reuse can be 20 times more effective at saving energy than recycling. But if the hardware ends up in a landfill site, shipping it overseas just defers the problem.

The danger is that schemes can encourage the view that PCs appear from nowhere and disappear equally easily, according to Empa project manager Mathias Schluep.

“When a PC reaches the end of its life, it still has to be recycled ­ it is just in Africa rather than in Europe,” he said.

“Some of these shipping charities are just glorified dumping schemes.”

Reader comments

In defence of Computer Aid

In response to Dave's comment above, I feel I should stand up for Computer Aid International. Computing has worked closely with the charity for some time and it is an excellent outfit. It does not make a penny from its work sending refurbished PCs to Africa and elsewhere - it is a charity and entirely non-profit making. Also, Computer Aid does go out of its way wherever possible to discuss end-of-life disposal of PCs it provides. In Kenya, for example, old Computer Aid PCs are entirely recycled - monitors get converted into televisions, components get re-used, even electrical heat sinks are used to make loudspeakers. See here for more details:
http://www.computing.co.uk/2183871.
With more resources, Computer Aid would no doubt be able to take more of a whole-life approach to the PCs it donates, but as a charity it has to prioritise. So far, PCs donated to Computer Aid by Computing readers have supported more than one million hours of teaching children in Africa. I think that's a pretty worthy cause.
Bryan Glick
Editor
Computing

Posted by: Bryan Glick  28 Sep 2007

PCs to Africa

HP's initiative is not before time. I don't know how effective it will be but there is no doubt that a large amount of the PCs shipped to Africa to 'help' them is simply scrap.
Computer Aid International must take some responsibility for this as they have made money out of sending IT equipment out to Africa without any kind of disposal policy in place. This was their reply to me when I asked them about this 18 months ago.
There are many other disposal companies making money by simply sending scrap to a third world country. How much better it would be if IT managers realised that it is their responsibility to dispose of their own equipment correctly. Re-use it or dispose of it with a reputable disposal company in this country.

Posted by: Dave  27 Sep 2007

Have your say on this article

All fields required. Your email address will not be displayed on the site.

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions

  • Digg
  • Tweet

Newsletters

Sign up for our FREE newsletters

Technology Patent Wars

Large companies such as Microsoft, Facebook and Google have been hoovering up technology patents recently. Is this stifling innovation?

88 %

5 %

7 %