piece of DNA
Police arresting to secure DNA

MPs to investigate police DNA arrests

Home affairs committee to look into claims that the police are arresting suspects to secure DNA for database

Written by Parliamentary reporter

The Commons Home Affairs Committee is to investigate a claim by government advisers that police are arresting suspects simply to secure DNA material for the database.

The allegation is contained in a report from the Human Genetics Commission. It comes from a letter from a retired police superintendent who said: "It has become the norm to arrest offenders where possible to obtain the DNA of the offender."

Samples of DNA can be taken after arrest but not where there is only a summons.

He said the past practice of using arrest powers and depriving a suspect of liberty only in the case of a serious offence or when the suspect was likely to flee, then using a summons to bring less serious offenders to a Magistrates Court, was no longer the norm.

The letter added: "It does not matter whether the arrest leads to no action, a caution or charge, because the DNA is kept on the database anyway.”

Liberty director of policy Isabella Sankey said this means the most sensitive information is being stockpiled against innocents who would previously never have been charged.

She added: "It also creates a perverse incentive to arrest people solely to get their details on the database."

The government is proposing changes to the DNA recording regime to make it comply with a critical European Court of Human Rights judgment but it will not be redrafting arrest rules. A Home Office spokesman claimed existing practice is right because the DNA database "is a vital crime-fighting tool".

In its report Nothing to Hide, Nothing to Fear, the commission said the database had been allowed to expand by "function creep" with no clear rules.

It feared young black men are being disproportionately stigmatised by being put on the database with no clear reason for doing so.

It demanded that the DNA of all police officers be stored to reinforce " trust".

Tory shadow Home Office Minister James Brokenshire said existing rules treated everyone as a potential suspect, and Lib Dem spokesman Chris Huhne accused the government of a "cavalier attitude" towards DNA data retention.

Commons Home Affairs Committee chairman Keith Vaz announced: we will launch an inquiry into the DNA database as a result of what we have seen.”

This inquiry will look at the number of people on the database, their ethnicity and the circumstances under which data is deleted.

He said: "We have decided to do an inquiry into the DNA database as a result of what we have seen today.”

Meanwhile, the Commons is considering new rules limiting the retention time for DNA data to six years.

The database is already the largest of its kind, with nearly six million profiles on one in 10 of the population. It has been created by the police without legislative authority.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print this
  • Share

reader comments

related articles

DNAPublic Sector

Innocents to be kept on DNA database for six years

Length halved from 12 years after pressure from opposition and campaigners 11 Nov 2009

 

Government uses dodgy case study to justify CPS proposals

The Home Office insists moor rescue was the result of communications data 13 Nov 2009

Government drops DNA proposals

Plan to keep innocent people on DNA database for 6 to 12 years dropped to push Bill through Lords 20 Oct 2009

More controversy over DNA database as MP's details removed

Tory Damian Green has his record deleted - and wants samples of other innocents removed as well 20 Aug 2009

DNA database placed on a statutory footing

Cross-party demands for changes to the Crime and Security Bill ignored 09 Mar 2010

Labour threatens to drop DNA retention proposals

Government may scrap six-year holding plan in face of opposition 07 Apr 2010

related white papers

today's top stories

Financial IT job market recovery continues

Recruitment growth suggests IT budgets are increasing 30 Jul 2010

Satellite broadband touted as digital divide clincher

KA-SAT launch promises 10Mbit/s service for hard-to-reach locations 29 Jul 2010

Ofcom slams ISPs for exaggerated broadband speed claims

New code of practice for ISPs planned by the regulator 27 Jul 2010

Aerohive offers traffic light Wi-Fi monitoring

Firm promises simple 'red, yellow or green' system with Client Health Score tool 27 Jul 2010

Flaw in top wireless security protocol WPA2 uncovered

Disgruntled insiders could hack corporate wireless LAN 26 Jul 2010

Advertisement

How to achieve business and financial-system implementation success
A look at how organisations - regardless of size - can work towards successful business software installations and factors that determine the outcome.

Case study: Specsavers put customer care into focus
How Specsavers captured customer feedback at point of sale and incorporated the results into its CRM system.

Advertisement

Citrix

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; IThound.com brings you thousands of white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

ICO to lean more heavily on public sector bodies

ICO to lean more heavily on public sector bodies

The ICO has said it will lean more heavily on public sector bodies to secure timely FOI responses, do you think this is:

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

picture of Jason HartVideo

Ethical hacker reveals the security secrets behind cloud computing

Jason Hart, Senior VP at Cryptocard, shows Computing just how easy it is to illegally gain access to corporate cloud services to wreak havoc and steal money. 29 Jun 2010

gartner logoVideo

Part 1: 2010 trends in SOA and Application Development and Integration

Gartner analyst Paolo Malinverno explores trends in SOA 29 Jun 2010

Latest in-depth articles

Map of 3G coverageComment

The risks of selling off the 800MHz radio spectrum at the wrong price

It's a choice between revenue now or universal broadband later 30 Jul 2010

Luton Borough Council officesAnalysis

Local authority leads the way in digital backup technology

Luton Borough Council tells of the benefits of early adopter of VTL, data deduplication and virtualisation 27 Jul 2010

Primary Navigation