British soldier
Problems "compounded safety risks" for British troops

Chinook software blunder "potentially put lives at risk" in Afghanistan

MPs attack Ministry of Defence after helicopters spend nine years on the ground

Written by Parliamentary reporter

A multimillion-pound software blunder by the Ministry of Defence (MoD) in its procurement of Chinook helicopters has deprived troops in Afghanistan of better air support and "potentially put the lives of British service personnel at greater risk", according to a damning report.

The Commons Public Accounts Committee (PAC) condemned the way the MoD handled the purchase of eight Mk3 helicopters from Boeing in 1995 without ensuring access to software code that is essential to certifying airworthiness.

Painfully slow progress was made in downgrading the Chinooks to enable them to be certified under a since-abandoned "fix to field" programme involving five years of negotiations with Boeing. None of the choppers have yet been put into service.

The committee said: "The absence of these helicopters has meant that British troops in Afghanistan have had to make do with fewer helicopters, make an increased number of dangerous journeys by road and, due to the specialist nature of the Mk3, rely on heavily modified Mk2 helicopters for use on high-risk special operations. The modification of the Mk2 Chinook cockpit to enable their use in low-light conditions was a far from perfect solution and compounded safety risks."

The cost of the helicopters has soared 70 per cent to £422m, or £52.5m each. Alternatives available when the order was placed "may have been cheaper", said the report.

The MoD has since moved from "fix to field" to a new "reversion" project drawn up without consulting Boeing.

Defence equipment minister Quentin Davies said he "entirely accepts the criticism that successive reports have made," but claimed there was "nothing new " in the latest PAC report, ignoring the disclosure that the new reversion programme has been adopted to get the machines into the air without checking costs with Boeing, resulting in an even higher bill.

Davies said the Chinooks were "a very bad case" and would remain "a lesson to us all".

The MPs said that "given that software is key to the operation of most modern defence equipment", it was "irresponsible" not to have made it a contractual requirement.

"The department should specify access to software as a clear requirement within any contract, especially where access to proprietary software is needed to provide airworthiness certification," they said.

Committee chairman Edward Leigh said: "The programme was hamstrung from the start by the appalling decision to buy the aircraft without securing access to their software source code.

"This meant that the MoD could not show that the cheaper, modified cockpit avionics which it had chosen met UK airworthiness standards and hence that the helicopters were safe to fly. ""

The Chinook Mk3 fleet was grounded because the contract with Boeing did not specify that software documentation and codes for avionics systems should be analysed in accordance with UK defence standards.

As a result, it was not possible to demonstrate that the helicopter’s flight instruments meet the required standards. So, instead of providing heavy-lift capacity to British troops, the choppers have spent nine years in RAF hangars.

The government said in January last year that it was to spend another £90m rectifying the software and avionics problems.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print this
  • Share

reader comments

related articles

British soldiers on manoeuvresHardware

MoD calls up small firms to reinforce military innovation

In a break with tradition, the MoD is looking to the UK’s smaller high-tech companies to help meet the military challenges of the future 05 Mar 2009

 

Three-quarters of MoD systems tested so far are not secure

Data handling review reveals extent of poor security standards 15 Jan 2009

£7bn defence IT project running 18 months late

EDS-led consortium criticised by MPs for underestimating complexity of software 15 Jan 2009

MoD may have misled parliament on defence IT project costs

Ministry of Defence knew total cost was £5.8bn when MPs were quoted a £2.3bn price tag 23 Oct 2008

Military up in arms over payment system failings

Members of armed forces continue to complain as system misses 16 Oct 2008

Chinooks grounded because MoD "wanted to fit its own software"

Reports claim ministry decided not to purchase Boeing avionics - a decision that has left helicopters grounded for 10 years 25 Aug 2009

First of eight mothballed Chinooks dispatched to Afghanistan

Move follows a £90m conversion programme undertaken by Boeing 11 Jan 2010

First two overhauled Chinooks handed over for active service

Six other revamped RAF helicopters, mothballed after an avionics computer codes gaffe, will be ready by the end of the year 14 Jan 2010

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Police hunt for moles with security software

Lancashire Constabulary to monitor data input of 7,000 staff in bid to prevent intelligence leaks 09 Feb 2010

PaperlinX outsources IT and comms to Bull and BT

Paper company spends €22m on five-year deal for desktop management, helpdesk and datacentre services 05 Feb 2010

Social tools take KM to a new level

Technology expert David Tebbutt explains how – and why – organisations should integrate social networking tools into their knowledge management strategy 02 Feb 2010

EDS court defeat puts vendors on their guard

BSkyB’s victory in a long-running court case against EDS has serious implications for the IT industry 02 Feb 2010

Law firm monitors web traffic violations

Bucks declining global security appliance sales with unified threat management (UTM) platform deployment 01 Feb 2010

Advertisement

Security: The New Face of Intrusion Prevention
An outline of traditional IPS functionality, modern developments and how IPS can be deployed easily.

UK businesses’ attitudes to Cloud Computing revealed

Features results from a survey of over 200 Computing readers.

Advertisement

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; ITHound.com brings you over 6,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

Internet Explorer 6

Internet Explorer 6

Following recent concerns about the security of Internet Explorer 6 are you planning to phase it out?

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Tony McAlisterVideo

Video Q&A: Tony McAlister, CTO, Betfair - Part one

On changing the skills development strategy at the online gambling firm - part one of a two-part video interview 05 Nov 2009

Video

Nokia shows upcoming handset technologies

Mobile phone features of tomorrow take the stage 21 Oct 2009

Latest in-depth articles

Analysis

Police hunt for moles with security software

Lancashire Constabulary to monitor data input of 7,000 staff in bid to prevent intelligence leaks 09 Feb 2010

Businessman with eye patch, dagger and tie round head, sitting at laptopFeatures

Are you sure you're not a pirate?

It is alarmingly easy for an IT leader to unwittingly exceed the scope of a software licence, and the chances of being caught out have never been greater, as technology lawyers Mark Weston and Paul Gershlick explain 09 Feb 2010

Primary Navigation