MoD wasted £120m on mismanaged IT

Department admits 'management weaknesses' led to project failure

Written by Sarah Arnott

A litany of management weaknesses was to blame for the waste of £120m of taxpayers' money on a failed inventory project, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has admitted.

The suspension of the £130m Defence Stores Management Solution (DSMS) was made public by Computing in November last year.

The MoD's annual report and accounts, published this week, say hardware valued at £12.2m has been salvaged from the project, but the remaining £118.3m investment was written off as a loss.

DSMS was to intended to create a common inventory and asset management system for the armed forces using predictive intelligence to streamline stock holdings.

The project started in 2000 as part of the Defence Logistics Organisation's (DLO's) wider Business Change Programme (BCP) and was expected to save £650m over 10 years.

The internal review at the end of 2002 to investigate the project's failure identifies management weaknesses at every level, comptroller and auditor general John Bourn says in the notes accompanying the MoD accounts.

Bourns's notes reveal: The MoD had no framework to assess and manage deliverability once projects were launched; the DLO lacked effective change management support and co-ordination; and the BCP suffered from poor financial governance, weak benefits management, poor communications and a failure to establish an effective programme management organisation.

'The review also noted weaknesses in the scrutiny and approvals process. Although BCP projects, including the DSMS, did not meet the Department's requirements in important areas - especially on affordability and benefits management - the projects were not rejected,' says Bourn.

The MoD says it has learned from the experience.

'We acknowledge that had better systems of change management been in place, with a tighter security and approvals process, then the programme might have been suspended earlier,' said a DLO spokesman.

'The DLO has moved to address these management system shortcomings with much tighter controls of proposed expenditure and predicted benefits.'

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

Public Sector 2002

Public Sector 2005

26 Jun 2004

 

MoD opts for SCO identity system

Vintela Authentication offers single sign-on to Windows and Unix systems 06 Apr 2004

Costly lessons in project control

Failed computer projects at the MoD illustrate the importance of tools and procedures for keeping progress on track 20 Nov 2003

CA posts flat profits

Currency fluctuation dents otherwise steady quarter 14 May 2009

Offender database a "masterclass" in sloppy management

Project to track all criminals in the UK from sentence to release is three years overdue and has increased in cost from £234m to £690m 12 Mar 2009

related whitepapers

today's top stories

How to maximise the value of your IT networking investment

A panel of experts discuss networking strategies that deliver real value to business 03 Jul 2009

Habitat gets a web site makeover

The furniture retailer is revamping its online presence to provide a fully transactional web site. CIO Jacques Dekock explains why 02 Jul 2009

Government aims to bolster UK's cyber defences

Is the UK’s first national cyber security strategy up to the task of co-ordinating the country’s response to digital threats? Computing investigates 02 Jul 2009

Focus resources on what really matters

IT has become too caught up in the drive for efficiency, at the expense of business success 02 Jul 2009

From tracks man to tax man

Phil Pavitt, outgoing chief information officer for Transport for London, talks to Rosalie Marshall about the lessons he will take to his new role at HMRC 02 Jul 2009

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Would you use social networking sites to look for a job?

Would you use social networking sites to look for a job?

Tell us what you think about job hunting through LinkedIn, Facebook, Twitter etc

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

network cablesVideo

How to maximise the value of your IT networking investment

A panel of experts discuss networking strategies that deliver real value to business 03 Jul 2009

green footprintsVideo

How to manage enterprise energy use - and the role IT can play

A panel of experts explore how firms can get to grips with their carbon footprint and make smarter use of energy 01 Jul 2009

Latest in-depth articles

Phil PavittAnalysis

From tracks man to tax man

Phil Pavitt, outgoing chief information officer for Transport for London, talks to Rosalie Marshall about the lessons he will take to his new role at HMRC 02 Jul 2009

UPS worker making a deliveryAnalysis

Global standardisation delivers benefits at UPS

Delivery giant sees benefits of central IT solution 02 Jul 2009

Advertisement

Primary Navigation