Robin Christopherson
Robin Christopherson

Security measures that penalise disabled users

Having to decipher distorted images might stop spam, but it also affects the disabled

Written by Robin Christopherson

Captcha ­- which stands for Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart -­ protects web sites against automatic and usually malicious programs that roam the internet trying to set up spam. They are tests that humans can pass but currently computers cannot.

The distorted image of a character sequence is the most commonly encountered form and usually appears as part of an online registration process.

If you cannot interpret the code and type it into a box, you are unable to register ­ but the majority of sites provide no alternative. Unless you crack the code, you are effectively locked out.

The problem with Captcha is that many humans cannot decipher the code either and nor can the technologies they commonly use, such as screen-reading software. If you have impaired vision, dyslexia or a learning disability, you may be unable to decipher the characters.

The accessibility armlock that Captcha represents is a problem for millions of users.
The most common alternative is an audio version of the graphical image, used by Google and Microsoft (but not Yahoo or YouTube), which provides a second chance at interpreting the code by speaking the characters aloud. But the audio distortion needed to obscure the code from malicious programs can make it almost impossible to hear.

Other alternatives are in the pipeline, including choosing descriptions of images from drop-down lists and asking the user to decide if a randomly rotated image is upright; but these still require some vision and the ability to deduce the image’s subject.

Other options use logic problems in text form ­ often too difficult for users with cognitive or learning disabilities ­ and a browser plug-in that is a useful tool but does not always work and demands Firefox as your browser.

Captchas are here to stay. But the only failsafe solution for those who require assistance is to have an obliging human on standby to wrestle with the
test on their behalf.

Robin Christopherson is head of accessibility at AbilityNet

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print this
  • Share

reader comments

related articles

Man at e-voting boothManagement

Breaking down barriers for accessible IT

While issues with e-voting systems for last week’s European elections gave accessibility campaigners yet another cause for complaint, there is growing evidence that the needs of people with disabilities are being taken seriously 11 Jun 2009

 

Time to bring anti-social technology to book

Technology should empower disabled users, not stigmatise and exclude them, writes David Banes 04 Jun 2009

Enabling IT for all

Carrie Saint Freedman explains how IT firms can address the issue of accessible technology 06 Mar 2008

Social-networking sites "locking users out"

But are not breaking disability discrimination laws 14 May 2009

Google buys ReCaptcha for security and scanning

Acquisition will cut fraud and help with book projects 17 Sep 2009

Report says spam rises in May

Symantec study shows spammers are becoming more intelligent 26 May 2009

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Police hunt for moles with security software

Lancashire Constabulary to monitor data input of 7,000 staff in bid to prevent intelligence leaks 09 Feb 2010

PaperlinX outsources IT and comms to Bull and BT

Paper company spends €22m on five-year deal for desktop management, helpdesk and datacentre services 05 Feb 2010

Social tools take KM to a new level

Technology expert David Tebbutt explains how – and why – organisations should integrate social networking tools into their knowledge management strategy 02 Feb 2010

EDS court defeat puts vendors on their guard

BSkyB’s victory in a long-running court case against EDS has serious implications for the IT industry 02 Feb 2010

Law firm monitors web traffic violations

Bucks declining global security appliance sales with unified threat management (UTM) platform deployment 01 Feb 2010

Advertisement

Security: The New Face of Intrusion Prevention
An outline of traditional IPS functionality, modern developments and how IPS can be deployed easily.

UK businesses’ attitudes to Cloud Computing revealed

Features results from a survey of over 200 Computing readers.

Advertisement

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; ITHound.com brings you over 6,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

Internet Explorer 6

Internet Explorer 6

Following recent concerns about the security of Internet Explorer 6 are you planning to phase it out?

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Tony McAlisterVideo

Video Q&A: Tony McAlister, CTO, Betfair - Part one

On changing the skills development strategy at the online gambling firm - part one of a two-part video interview 05 Nov 2009

Video

Nokia shows upcoming handset technologies

Mobile phone features of tomorrow take the stage 21 Oct 2009

Latest in-depth articles

Analysis

Police hunt for moles with security software

Lancashire Constabulary to monitor data input of 7,000 staff in bid to prevent intelligence leaks 09 Feb 2010

Businessman with eye patch, dagger and tie round head, sitting at laptopFeatures

Are you sure you're not a pirate?

It is alarmingly easy for an IT leader to unwittingly exceed the scope of a software licence, and the chances of being caught out have never been greater, as technology lawyers Mark Weston and Paul Gershlick explain 09 Feb 2010

Primary Navigation