Tom Young

Data watchdog must prepare to be hounded

The next Information Commissioner will have to cope with intense scrutiny from the media and politicians

Written by Tom Young

The next Information Commissioner will be under the spotlight

 

The new powers awarded to the Information Commissioner recently have been well trailed by the government for more than a year. Indeed, they were trotted out as a response every time the government suffered another data loss, as if a more powerful commissioner would be some sort of panacea. It won’t.

I am often asked why I think government data losses ­ not exactly scintillating stories ­ have become the stuff of headlines.

The answer is threefold.

First, HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC). The loss of 25 million child benefit records was a huge blow for the government and undermined Gordon Brown’s carefully crafted image as a safe pair of hands. If the hands are not safe, and their owner was presiding over an increasingly authoritarian government, this was a worrying chain of events.

The media love a narrative in the vein of “recent event illustrates larger problem” and here they have a story that will run and run.

Second, ID cards. However much the government tries to bill this initiative as a new type of passport, the public remain unconvinced.

The ID card scheme is stuck between a rock and a hard place. ID cards play into the left-wing media’s concerns over the erosion of civil liberties and the right-wing media’s concerns over a growing nanny state. The success of the Conservatives in linking every data loss story to the theoretical vulnerability of the National Identity Register has added grist to the mill.

Which brings us to the third reason: David Davis. By making opposition to the growing “database state” a tenet of his by-election campaign the former shadow home secretary helped keep data loss in the headlines.

One result of all this media attention is the profile of the Information Commissioner. Current incumbent Richard Thomas found himself thrust into the limelight ­ and after years of calling for stronger powers he now has them.

Opinions are mixed on Thomas’s reign. He comes from a legal background in a field that is becoming increasingly dominated by technology. Recently his office has suffered a huge backlog of cases as well as staffing problems, with many of the commission’s lawyers leaving.

But nobody could claim that data protection has not risen up the news agenda under Thomas’s stewardship.

However, his yet-to-be-appointed successor, due to take over in June 2009, will have a different job to the one Thomas inherited. The job will be more politicised, it will become the object of more media focus, and the new commissioner will be expected to keep government use of personal information in check.

Whoever is appointed must be up to speed with technology ­ many think somebody from an IT background would be suitable.

But just how much will the Information Commissioner’s powers help solve the government data loss problem?

Changing the culture of government will be no mean feat, especially at a time when technology is enabling more information sharing. Even though the fines that can be levied have increased, they are still a token gesture. What really matters is the adverse publicity of a data breach.

The national media is far more attuned to incidents of data loss than ever before, so the Information Commissioner can make an enormous splash through a carefully timed press release. And that means political paymasters will be keeping a gimlet-eyed lookout on the commissioner’s activities.

Instead of struggling to raise the profile of data protection, as Richard Thomas had to do, it seems more likely that the next commissioner will face more of a challenge keeping some distance from politicians from all sides.

reader comments

related articles

richard thomasManagement

ICO launches new privacy report

Information Commissioner's Office urges organisations to design privacy into their information systems from the start 26 Nov 2008

 

Experts welcome new Information Commissioner powers

Sharpening of data protection watchdog's teeth should reduce security breaches 25 Nov 2008

Straw bulks up Information Commissioner's powers

Spot checks, greater fines and higher salary as data protection becomes paramount 24 Nov 2008

Privacy tzar speaks out against data breach notification laws

But Information Commissioner admits breach levels remain worrying 29 Oct 2008

MPs slam MoD loss of 1.7 million records

And government warns that more losses could yet be uncovered 14 Oct 2008

West Midlands Police loses data stick

IPCC to investigate latest in a long line of public sector data losses 16 Sep 2008

Protests at government surveillance grow

1,500 attend public meeting to warn of database dangers 02 Mar 2009

related whitepapers

today's top stories

What does Windows 7 mean for Microsoft?

With the sting of Vista still fresh, Redmond has to make next Windows work 10 Jul 2009

A smarter way to use BI

Getting the most from business intelligence systems requires not only careful management on the part of IT leaders, but also the committed involvement of decision-makers across the organisation 08 Jul 2009

Quenching a thirst for IT modernisation

A substantial restructure at soft drink supplier Nichols -­ purveyor of Vimto - ­led the company to update its software to Sage 1000 to replace its in-house application. This resulted in the streamlining of the IT department and an opportunity to customise the system 08 Jul 2009

How Satyam cleaned up its act

Chief executive CP Gurnani tells Angelica Mari why Tech Mahindra opted to keep the Satyam brand after it bought the scandal-hit services firm, and explains what the deal means for existing and prospective customers 09 Jul 2009

Lack of enterprise appeal takes shine off Chrome OS

Enterprise buyers unlikely to ditch Windows for Chrome OS in the near term, say experts 09 Jul 2009

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Advertisement

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Will Google Chrome OS be a genuine alternative to Windows?

Will Google Chrome OS be a genuine alternative to Windows?

Tell us your views on the new operating system rivalry

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

network cablesVideo

How to maximise the value of your IT networking investment

A panel of experts discuss networking strategies that deliver real value to business 03 Jul 2009

green footprintsVideo

How to manage enterprise energy use - and the role IT can play

A panel of experts explore how firms can get to grips with their carbon footprint and make smarter use of energy 01 Jul 2009

Latest in-depth articles

Google ChromeAnalysis

Lack of enterprise appeal takes shine off Chrome OS

Enterprise buyers unlikely to ditch Windows for Chrome OS in the near term, say experts 09 Jul 2009

Satyam CEO CP GurnaniNews

How Satyam cleaned up its act

Chief executive CP Gurnani tells Angelica Mari why Tech Mahindra opted to keep the Satyam brand after it bought the scandal-hit services firm, and explains what the deal means for existing and prospective customers 09 Jul 2009

Advertisement

Primary Navigation