VIEW FROM THE HOUSE - Failings point to need for revenue committee

A parliamentary body is needed to monitor the efficiency of Customsand the Inland Revenue.

Written by John Stylianou

Every year, the Public Accounts Committee, on which I sit, conducts a routine review of the work of both Customs & Excise and, separately, the Inland Revenue.

In the week of 10 March, we held a special hearing into the work of Customs in seizing the assets of drug dealers followed by the normal Revenue hearing. Both provided fascinating insights into failings in our system of getting revenue for the state.

What we heard from Customs was depressing. It is only a few years since it was first given powers to seize drug-dealers' assets. The powers it has are limited by statute and subject to considerable delay in court process (Customs can only start looking for the assets when someone has been found guilty, often years after the offence) and co-operation is frequently against the best financial interests of the drug dealer who seeks to preserve a means of living for when he leaves prison.

Customs needs greater powers to seize assets and act earlier in cases of suspected drug dealers. It also needs a much greater level of forensic expertise and more regular public scrutiny of its work, purely as a spur to success.

Reporting on the introduction of self-assessment, the Revenue was less able to conceal its blunders.

Despite greater staff training which has led, in general, to brighter and more constructive telephone conversations between accountants and the Revenue as a means of settling clients' affairs, errors have already crept into the self-assessment process. Revenue officials were unconvincing in suggesting that all was well.

Sir Anthony Battishill, chairman of the Board of the Inland Revenue, even tried to suggest that what he insisted on calling 'statements of tax due from the self-employed' had been working.

This when the world knows that these statements were not just due to be issued to the self-employed, but also to taxpayers with savings income received gross. Some taxpayers did not receive them, while the level of error, particularly regarding savings income on which the tax due was incorrectly requested in two installments, was so great that the Revenue has already lost an unspecified amount of interest on late payment.

What is, of course, frightening in both of these areas is that the sums of money lost are of such size in real terms as to make any other department of state drool. When Customs decides, as a matter of policy, not to make enquiries in the worldwide banking system in respect of a particular criminal suspected of concealing substantial assets or when the Revenue foregoes interest on a category of late payments, then the issue of Parliamentary scrutiny is bound to come up.

Maybe what we need is a supplementary body to the Public Accounts Committee: a Public Revenue Committee, operating on the same lines as the PAC but looking solely at the efficiency of the revenue-collecting departments.

It would highlight areas where the system of tax-collection is not functioning as well as it might. Such a committee could, for example, have drawn attention to the income tax cost of BES loanbacks some months before the Government took action.

More power to the PRC. Now that's a slogan you won't hear from campaigning politicians over the next month.

Michael Stern is Conservative MP for Bristol North West.

  • Have your say
  • Send to a friend
  • Print this
  • Share

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

 

related whitepapers

today's top stories

Face facts: social media is the future

No organisation can afford to ignore the way business communications are changing 18 Mar 2010

Is the data watchdog about to pounce?

Experts believe the Information Commissioner’s Office is itching to use its new power to impose hefty fines for data breaches. Martin Courtney reports 18 Mar 2010

Lloyd’s of London gears up for regulation

CIO Peter Hambling tells Angelica Mari about how the insurance market has updated its IT infrastructure to comply with new regulations 18 Mar 2010

Protests greet new Digital Economy Bill amendment

ISPs, digital rights groups and Liberal Democrat supporters cry foul 05 Mar 2010

IT Leaders' Forum in association with IBM

A unique opportunity to hear from expert speakers and engage in a debate about the future of the CIO job function 29 Jan 2010

Advertisement

Keys to successful Service‐Oriented Architecture implementation

This white paper explores best practices and general design patterns for service oriented architecture (SOA).

The Roadmap to IT Maturity — Matching Strategy to Infrastructure for Business Success

This paper defines a roadmap for matching infrastructure strategy to business success.

Advertisement

Keep up to date with the latest products, services and technologies from the world's leading IT companies; ITHound.com brings you over 6,000 white papers, case studies and analyst reports.

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

More available - click 'submit' to view

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Related jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job

IT Salary Checker

Check salary here

Advertisement

Latest poll

NHS centralised data

NHS centralised data

Do you think the NHS can be trusted to safely look after personal data electronically?

View poll results

Latest audio and video articles

Video

HP unveils S Series notebooks

'Prosumer' line overhauled 01 Mar 2010

Web Seminar Listings

Preparing for enterprise-scale Windows 7 migration

The web seminar on 18 Feb will discuss how Windows 7 migration can increase IT efficiency in large enterprises, freeing up budgetary and personnel resources to focus on business innovation. Our panel of experts will examine the strategies, tools and services IT leaders can use to migrate successfully and reap the rewards of increased efficiency. 19 Feb 2010

Latest in-depth articles

Derek FindlayComment

Hot Seat: Derek Findlay

Derek Findlay is computing support officer at the University of Aberdeen where he works with a team of more than 20 people 18 Mar 2010

David ChanComment

Do we want to play musical chairs?

More attention to training and development would improve IT staff retention and reduce costs 18 Mar 2010

Primary Navigation