Mark Samuels
Samuels: Good luck with your magic quadrants

Making best use of Gartner's reports

IT chiefs should be careful about relying on research to justify their IT spending in the face of a potential recession

Written by Mark Samuels

An IT leader said to me recently that analyst Gartner is a bit like the new Big Blue. The commonly used adage suggests no IT manager ever got sacked for choosing IBM. And the technology chief suggested the saying now worked for Gartner - ­ certainly in a strategic sense, anyway.

The credit crunch and ever-deepening recession means justifying new IT investment is harder than ever.

Problem is, of course, many of the potential benefits from modern business technology projects sound a bit esoteric.

Forget simple efficiency metrics, the most important initiatives create fluffy benefits such as integration, collaboration and knowledge.

And going to the finance director with a qualitative list is a bit like the proverbial chocolate teapot: useless.

The ongoing downturn means the board wants big, juicy numbers ­ a quantitative value it can associate with a technology implementation.

Enter the IT manager’s good friend Gartner, keeper of the magic quadrant and king of the buzzword.

Line-of-business executives often struggle to understand the bits and bytes of technology. But the business likes Gartner; it likes how reports can be produced to justify technology spending.

The IT leader told me the boon of such an approach is simple: your boss believes Gartner. All of which means the IT manager can justify their project.

But taking business executives on a trip to the wonderful world of Gartner also has its bad points. Show your boss the source of your knowledge and it can come back to bite you.

Recoil in horror as the chief executive enters your office and asks if you have seen the latest research from Gartner. How do you tell your boss to keep their nose out, especially when he is clutching the latest announcement from Gartner vice president Ken McGee, who says the worst consequences of the recession can be prevented by “countering innovation with innovation”?

Sounds a bit like a tautology to me, except the second word is exactly the same as the first.

Good luck blending quadrants and tautology in an attempt to secure project funding. My guess is you will need it.

What do you think? Read Mark Samuels’ blog at: http://knowledge.computing.co.uk

Tags:

reader comments

related articles

Picture of Mark Samuels

We will all become more touchy-feely

The reign of the mouse could be at an end as motion-sensing devices become more popular and easy to use, says Mark Samuels 03 Apr 2008

 

Elearning disaster ignored users' needs

Concerns over marketing and content at UKeU were secondary 10 Mar 2005

Time to focus on the good in databases

The media breeds a lack of confidence in databases, but good management shows the more positive possibilities, says Mark Samuels 27 Mar 2008

The head spinning world of Web 2.0

Social software has still not shown its business benefits and firms should try to keep up with the constant changes, says Mark Samuels 20 Mar 2008

The future does not look bright for IT

Big changes are afoot if the IT industry is to survive and develop in the next few years, but how best to go about it, asks Mark Samuels 13 Mar 2008

Innovation can battle the credit crunch

IT departments must be allowed to identify and solve business problems, says Gartner 08 Apr 2008

Gartner Advises IT Leaders to Prepare Two IT Budgets for 2008

At its Symposium event in Cannes, the analyst firm warns IT managers to have a backup budget ready 07 Nov 2007

today's top stories

Analysis: Will IE8 cause more problems than it solves?

Microsoft's new browser may lead to compatibility issues and affect online advertising 29 Aug 2008

CIO morale plummets as crunch hits

Fewer opportunities and less responsibility depress IT managers 27 Aug 2008

The pIT stop Q&A: Should packaged software users adopt SOA?

Our expert panel answer readers' questions 29 Aug 2008

Computing podcast 28 August 2008

CIO job satisfaction plummets, and why schools' IT spending is set to top £1bn 28 Aug 2008

The definitive guide to collaboration

Five key technologies and five best practice tips to improve your collaborative IT 28 Aug 2008

Advertisement

Newsletter signup

Sign up for our range of FREE newsletters:

Existing User

Newsletter user login:

Jobs

Job of the week

Job alerts

Sign up here

Find your next job here

Advertisement

White papers

Search white papers

Top categories

VPN, Extranet and Intranet Solutions

WAN/ LAN Solutions

Network Security

Interoperability-Connectivity

Grid/ Utility Computing

Latest poll

Would you recruit a student with an IT degree?

Would you recruit a student with an IT degree?

As IT student numbers plummet - would you recruit an IT graduate?

Previous poll results

Latest audio and video articles

A stressed CIOAudio

Computing podcast 28 August 2008

CIO job satisfaction plummets, and why schools' IT spending is set to top £1bn 28 Aug 2008

Bryan Glick video whiteboardVideo

The definitive guide to collaboration

Five key technologies and five best practice tips to improve your collaborative IT 28 Aug 2008

Latest in-depth articles

Myron HrycykAnalysis

General management skills are now as important as technical ability

A selection of leading chief information officers talk about what they see as the most important aspects of the role 28 Aug 2008

Internet Explorer logoAnalysis

Analysis: Will IE8 cause more problems than it solves?

Microsoft's new browser may lead to compatibility issues and affect online advertising 29 Aug 2008

Primary Navigation